Roxanne would need little encouragement not to put this movie on

“Red Lights” is one of those movies which sounded good in theory but fell flat in practice. In theory, you have Sigourney Weaver, Cillian Murphy, Toby Jones and Robert DeNiro in a film which looks set to play out as a serious thriller version of “Ghostbusters”. In practice, you’ve got something that’s not sure whether it’s a scientific thriller or thrilling pseudo-science.

The film opens with University Academic Margaret Matheson (Weaver) and her assistant, Physicist Tom Buckley (Murphy) investigating and debunking incidents of alleged paranormal activity interspersed with media coverage of legendary blind celebrity Psychic Simon Silver (DeNiro) announcing his comeback from a self-imposed seclusion.

As investigators, Matheson and Buckley are actually pretty engaging but the film quickly side-lines their on-going investigations and work as lecturers in favour of a slightly overcooked melodrama involving Simon Silver’s return to the limelight, Buckley’s Ahab-like obsession with exposing him and Matheson’s reluctance to investigate him again after an emotionally upsetting encounter years before where Silver invoked the spirit of her comatose son during their confrontation.

As Buckley’s obsession grows, he decides to pursue the investigation against Silver independently, despite a series of increasingly disturbing and inexplicable events plaguing him. Unfortunately, the movie throws logic and science out of the window and ends up treading a more clichéd and predictable path.

Weaver and DeNiro are as reliably excellent as you would expect. Cillian Murphy also does well as the driven Tom Buckley, and it’s nice to see him in a heroic leading role for once. Toby Jones as Matheson’s rival academic Dr Paul Shackleton and Joely Richardson as Silver’s Manager Monica Handsen are wasted as underwritten cyphers while the talents of Elizabeth Olsen are criminally underused in a purely decorative role as Buckley’s girlfriend.

This”Red Lights” is very much a film of two halves, and the first forty-five or so minutes are great. However, once the ‘shock event’ is delivered in the middle of the film, it drifts off course and writer/ director Rodrigo Cortés’ ambition is revealed. Unfortunately, the final revelation only serves to show how far short of his aim he fell. This is way, way off the marketing hype promise of ‘This year’s “The Sixth Sense”!’

If Cortés had kept this a taught thriller about dedicated and serious scientists myth-busting their way to a final confrontation with a cynical and ruthless hoaxer we could have had something really special. Instead, he gives us a muddled and illogical ‘surprise twist’, undermining all the good work he has done. Cortés has no need to imitate in order to succeed, so it’s a shame he chose to here. After all, we already have a director who desperately tries to replicate the magic of early Shyamalan films – he’s called M. Night Shyamalan.

red lights review
Score 5/10
logo

Related posts

9th Anniversary Post

9th Anniversary Post

...and we're back! Nine years ago today, What The Craggus Saw made its debut with a modestly adequate review of the modestly adequate romcom I Give It A Year. And now, here we are, three thousand, two hundred and eighty-seven days, one thousand six hundred and seventy-five...

Ready Player One (2018) Review

Ready Player One (2018) Review

Ready Player One is a curate's Easter egg of a movie As Easter eggs go, “Ready Player One” is akin to one of those ones that come in a super-fancy package, with an intricate box and plenty of gold foil. Unfortunately, for large parts of the movie, it’s just as hollow and...

Godless Season One

Godless Season One

Mister X comes over all evangelical about Godless. Lauded Hollywood screenwriter Scott Frank (“Out Of Sight”, “Minority Report”, “Logan”) brings a refreshing tale of a plucky band of women’s struggle with life in the Wild West to the small screen in his first foray into the medium as a...

300: Rise Of An Empire (2014) Review

300: Rise Of An Empire (2014) Review

It's my 300th post, so what better film to review than the appropriately titled 300: Rise Of An Empire? A belated follow-up to 2006’s “300”, this part prequel/ part ‘side-quel’/ sort of sequel by necessity discards much of the principle cast of the first film to focus on events in the...

Craggus’ Trek Trek: Now, Voyager! Vol 10

Craggus' Trek Trek: Now, Voyager! Vol 10

Craggus' Trek Trek:Now, Voyager! Vol 10 Craggus' Trek Trek Now Voyager Vol 10 sees Voyager's fourth season really hit its stride and deliver one of the series' best two parters into the bargain as it leans into what the entire series should have been like. Star Trek Voyager...

The Secret Life Of Pets (2016) Review

The Secret Life Of Pets (2016) Review

The Secret Life Of Pets is consistently almost great If you were to make a movie about the secret life of my family pet, our cat Rufus, it would probably have to be set at night because what he does during the day is sleep. However, given he’s sometimes turned up at the back door...

47 Ronin (2013) Review

47 Ronin (2013) Review

It’s hard to write a review for a mediocre film. Neither particularly good nor particularly bad, the lack of distinguishing features makes it hard to find a hook to hang the write-up on. Great films are easier, because the passion and enthusiasm they provoke make you want to share...

Cats & Dogs: Paws Unite (2020) Review

Cats & Dogs: Paws Unite (2020) Review

Call the humane society, Cats & Dogs: Paws Unite needs to be put to sleep An un-retrieved stick’s throw away from the likeable original and even the inferior sequel, this cheap and cheerless threequel borders on animal abuse and certainly qualifies as audience cruelty. That...