Kidman & Firth reunite onscreen for dark and gritty “50 First Dates” reimagining Before I Go To Sleep

Superficially, it’s easy to look at “Before I Go To Sleep” as a gritty and dark reimagining of “50 First Dates” with Nicole Kidman taking over from Drew Barrymore and Colin Firth in the Adam Sandler role. Which would make Mark Strong, um, Rob Schneider I guess? But where the 2004 Rom Com went for sunny romance and screwball antics, this taut psychological thriller explores a much more sinister take on anterograde amnesia.

When Christine (Nicole Kidman in full wide-and-darting-eyed mode) awakes in a strange bed next to an unfamiliar man (Colin Firth), she learns that she is suffering from memory loss as the results of an accident several years previously and despite the fact her last memories are of her early twenties, she is over 40 years old and the stranger in bed beside her is her husband Ben. Every night, her memory resets and she forgets everything, having to repeat the same process of shock and discovery day after day. However, working with her psychologist Dr Nash (Mark Strong), Christine has been keeping a video diary and as it starts to help her retain a semblance of a normal life, she begins to suspect that neither man can be trusted.

Director Rowan Joffé shoots the film with a dreamy, ambient feel echoing Christine’s sense of detachment and disorientation while the cinematography is starkly bleak, a combination of sodium-drenched ambers and washed-out blues echoing the aesthetic of those oh-so-trendy Scandinavian TV thrillers. Kidman, Firth and Strong deliver skilful performances, each leaving just enough ambiguity that you’ll vacillate over who might be keeping secrets from whom as the inconsistencies and clues gather like autumn leaves. While you may see the twist coming, the reveal is such a shocking moment that it gives the whole film a shot of adrenalin and jolts you upright in your seat just as you might be considering going to sleep yourself.

It may not reward repeated viewings as much as other thrillers of its ilk, but it’s a satisfying take on the amnesiac premise and it’s trim running time of 92 minutes means it gets across the finish line long before the necessary plot contrivances start to undermine your enjoyment.

before i go to sleep review
Score 7/10


Hi there! If you enjoyed this post, why not sign up to get new posts sent straight to your inbox?

Sign up to receive a weekly digest of The Craggus' latest posts.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

logo

Related posts

The Big Sick (2017) Review

The Big Sick (2017) Review

More than a 'While You Were Sleeping' for the new millennium. Sweet, funny and poignantly insightful, “The Big Sick” is a perfectly pitched romantic comedy semi-autobiographical memoir of how star Kumail Nanjiani met his real-life wife. Kumail is making a living as an Uber driver as...

After Earth (2013) Review

After Earth (2013) Review

Lacking in heart, the Smiths to blame, this film gives nepotism a bad name I’ve previously suggested that 2013 was a pretty good year for sci-fi, but it wasn’t all Romulan Ale & Triffids (okay, you come up with a better sci-fi version of wine & roses). In amongst all the...

United Passions (2015) Review

United Passions (2015) Review

From Corruption, With Love. Celebrating the start of the World Cup with a review of United Passions With the World Cup kicking off in Russia today, what better time to review that great footballing drama “United Passions”? Inspired by actual events but mendaciously crafted to launder the...

Graveyard Shift (1990) Review

Graveyard Shift (1990) Review

Is Pepsi okay? Graveyard Shift is one of those adaptations that scrabbles through the grime of Stephen King’s short fiction and comes up clutching a big, sweaty clump of creature feature pulp. It’s not really a faithful translation of King’s moody, rat-infested morality tale so much...

The Devil’s Advocate (1997) Review

The Devil's Advocate (1997) Review

The Devil's in the details, so always check the small print. The Devil’s Advocate is a film that straddles the line between legal thriller and supernatural horror with devilish glee, offering a compelling, stylish, and surprisingly thought-provoking ride. At the heart of this Faustian...

I Know What You Did Last Summer (2025) Review

I Know What You Did Last Summer (2025) Review

It knows how things were done last century. There's profound irony in 2025's I Know What You Did Last Summer being an "Original Films" production given there's barely a single frame of originality in it. Sadly, it's the only irony on offer for a movie that's so lacking a sense of the...