What are the odds this Hunger Games: Mockingjay Part 1 Review is in its favour?

I’m not a fan of the growing trend for artificially prolonging a franchise by splitting the last instalment into two parts. There are reasons why trilogies evolved as a dominant storytelling structure rather than tetralogies, even though tetralogy sounds a lot cooler. The “Harry Potter” franchise just about got away with it (thanks to the source booking being huge) but “The Hunger Games” third and final book adaptation into “The Hunger Games: Mockingjay Part 1” and “Part 2” doesn’t fare nearly so well.

Partly, this comes from the (necessary) abandonment of the story’s core concept: the games themselves and partly from the cast who seem numbed and detached, not be the horrors of war and poverty but by the banality and drudgery of a script with too little incident and too much time on its hands. Characters have in-world conversations about whether or not Katniss Everdeen is capable of being the Mockingjay and argue over which Katniss they have rescued. I’ll tell you which one you’ve got: the one from the first movie; the one who seemed disinterested and underwhelming, completely unconvincing as a figurehead for a revolutionary movement.

It’s not just Jennifer Lawrence’s fault either, as the rest of the cast seem subdued as well, with only Elizabeth Banks and John Hutcherson getting the opportunity to breathe real life into their characters. In fact it’s only once Banks’ Effie Trinket, shorn of all her finery, pops up that the film comes to life at all. Despite having rescued the franchise with the aggressive, kinetic and thrilling “Catching Fire”, director Francis Lawrence seems at a loss as to how to structure this tale now it’s been cut in two. There are far too many scenes of Katniss moping around, reluctant to embrace her destiny or even help the people who need her. The script, a surprising let-down from the usually excellent Danny Strong, mostly constrains Katniss to either tearful or angrily tearful.

The film also singularly fails to show why Katniss should be so eager to side with District 13’s President Coin. The previous films may have demonstrated just why President Snow should be overthrown but it’s hard to shake the impression that installing Coin in his place and allowing her to impose her totalitarian communist society across PanEm would be any better. The world built to support the Hunger Games story has always been a bit of a strain on credibility and devoid of the action-packed bread and circuses centrepiece, the cracks really start to show. District 13 is not a pleasant place to be, and it’s not clear that this is all out of necessity. We’re also told (repeatedly) that both leaders are master tacticians and strategists using the most cunning and subtle of ploys yet every move Snow makes is telegraphed in advance by an almost Batman villain-like need to monologue and give little clues to his plots. Easily foreseeable events take even the most battle-hardened soldiers and leaders by surprise while the only tactic Coin seems to favour, regardless of the military objective, is to throw wave after wave of cannon fodder at the enemy until they run out of ammo. In itself, that may be the bravest and most interesting thing this film does as it tries hard to replace momentum with commentary on the futility and brutality of war.

When it rouses itself, it manages to be intense and spectacular but these set-pieces are so few and far between that they only serve to highlight the grimly humourless and threadbare nature of the script. There is still a chance the overall story will be redeemed by Part 2, which is less than a year away but with a disengaging lead-in like this, the odds are no longer in its favour.

mockingjay part 1 review
Score 6/10
logo

Related posts

Once Bitten (1985) Review

Once Bitten (1985) Review

Vampire comedy Once Bitten lacks bite but still manages to suck. Available right now on Netflix, "Once Bitten" is a decidedly anaemic sex comedy that's been consigned to the crypt of forgotten Eighties comedies. But is it time for it to rise from the tomb once more? The Countess...

Godzilla vs Kong (2021) Review

Godzilla vs Kong (2021) Review

Godzilla Vs Kong finally brings us a big-screen showdown where whoever loses, the audience wins. There’s something reassuringly predictable about GODZILLA vs KONG, an adherence to convention that lets you stop worrying about some out-of-left-field twist or clever subversion and...

Violent Night (2022) Review

Violent Night (2022) Review

Voilent Night, Holy Shit! Christmas movies are no strangers to darkness and violence (Black Christmas, Better Watch Out, Terrifier 3) but few do it with such polish and joie de guignol as Violent Night. This audacious holiday action-comedy expertly blends yuletide cheer with R-rated...

X-Men: The Last Stand (2006) Review

X-Men: The Last Stand (2006) Review

The anti-juggernaut of the X-Men movies, The Last Stand robs the saga of its momentum. After the triumph of X2, expectations were sky-high for the third instalment, but with franchise kingpin Bryan Singer off directing Superman Returns – a film which would cost X-Men: The Last Stand more...

Mrs America is a fascinating chronicle of the formation of the fault lines which continue to divide America today

Mrs America is a fascinating chronicle of the formation of the fault lines which continue to divide America today

Looking at the American body politic today, it’s easy to assume that the bitter divisions are something of a recent manifestation, a cancerous corrosion accelerated by the devastation of 9/11 and toxically perfected in the weaponised division of President Trump but “Mrs America” sheds a...

A Haunting In Venice (2023) Review

A Haunting In Venice (2023) Review

The Little Grey Cells Confront some dark shadows in A Haunting In Venice Hercule Poirot, the man who can solve a murder with a stray shoelace and a misplaced button, faces his most perplexing case yet – a rendezvous with the supernatural in the canals of Venice. Does A Haunting in...

Hellboy (2004) Review

Hellboy (2004) Review

Hellboy smashes his way into the superhero cinematic pantheon. In 2004, Hellboy was summoned to the big screen under the inspired direction of Guillermo del Toro, bringing Mike Mignola’s beloved comic book creation to life with a perfect blend of dark fantasy, pulpy action, and a...

Hitchcock (2012) Review

Hitchcock (2012) Review

Hitchcock (2012) Review “Hitchcock” sets out to tell the story of celebrated director Alfred Hitchcock’s biggest career risk, the making of “Psycho”. The man himself is portrayed by an at times unrecognisable Anthony Hopkins, who plays him with an impish imperiousness, and all the...