Fame costs, and Miles Teller pays with blood, sweat & tears in intense psychological drama Whiplash

“Whiplash” tells a story you will have seen before. The story of a young and talented protégé who is taken on by an unconventional and driven mentor determined to propel them both to greatness whatever the cost. It’s the well-worn trope of a dozen sports movies and even more army boot camp films but “Whiplash” rises above its clichéd story beats thanks to its fresh setting and the potent and ferocious central performances from Miles Teller and J K Simmons.

Set in the fictional New York Shaffer Conservatory, the finest music school in America, Teller plays Andrew Neiman, a young and talented drummer who aspires to become one of the greats of Jazz drumming. He is spotted by fearsome Shaffer conductor Terence Fletcher (Simmons) and recruited into the house band. But Fletcher’s demanding and abusive style begin to take their toll on Andrew as he obsessively works to win his mentor’s approval.

If you found the soundtrack of “Birdman” irksome, then this might not be the film for you as drumming is front and centre, as a blistering and bloody crucible. Miles Teller impresses with a multi-layered performance as the ambitious, arrogant but untempered drummer (and continues to be one of the few hopes I have for the “Fantastic Four” movie to be anything other than a train wreck) and his dedication to the role means he literally puts his own blood, sweat and tears into the insanely punishing jazz percussion routines.

But it’s J K Simmons’ Terence Fletcher who will linger longest in your memory. In Fletcher, Simmons has created one of 21st Century cinema’s greatest monsters. Capable of switching from quite kindness to demonic intensity on an apparent whim, he’s a truly terrifying, monstrously cruel and vindictive creation, ruthlessly justifying his viciousness as a necessity to uncover true talent. He is the distilled essence of the philosophy of tough love and being cruel to be kind.

Yes, the film largely follows a conventional ‘Fame costs’ path and relies too heavily on repeated references to an apocryphal story about Charlie “The Bird” Parker while pushing the increasingly discredited theory that practice alone makes perfect but the central performances elevate the material far beyond its limitations. When the film finally casts off the shackles of its familiar story with a breath-taking third act twist as the intense psychological war of attrition between Andrew and Fletcher reaches its astonishing climax, it delivers not only a master class in both acting and cinema but a powerful and mesmeric finale.

whiplash review
Score 9/10


Hi there! If you enjoyed this post, why not sign up to get new posts sent straight to your inbox?

Sign up to receive a weekly digest of The Craggus' latest posts.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

logo

Related posts

Fight Or Flight (2025) Review

Fight Or Flight (2025) Review

Chocks away for Hartnett's Bullet Train in the sky. It’s a good thing air travel is statistically the safest way to travel because if Fight or Flight were even remotely realistic, nobody would ever board a plane again. Josh Hartnett, rocking a peroxide blonde look that lands somewhere...

Hot Air (2016) Review

Hot Air (2016) Review

Hot Air provides a great deal of warmth. Winner of the Comedy Vanguard Jury Award at the Austin Film Festival 2016, “Hot Air” is a quirky and gentle romantic comedy which starts with…ahem…a bang. ‘Major’ (Jere Burns) is an incorrigible conman who fakes his own death under his real...

Mega Shark vs Kolossus (2015) Review

Mega Shark vs Kolossus (2015) Review

Mega Shark vs Kolossus is a kolossal waste of time and energy Sometime in the future, the world has yet to recover from the last mega shark attack. A voiceover tells us that the near total halt of global shipping plus a general avoidance of the coast and water by the population of...

Mile 22 (2018) Review

Mile 22 (2018) Review

You’d have to get up pretty early in the morning to find a more obnoxious film than Mile 22. “Mile 22” is a movie every bit as toxically moronic, tone-deaf and self-flagellating as a daily schedule which starts the day at 2:30am for literally no good reason. It’s a hateful, ignorant and...

Earth To Echo (2014) Review

Earth To Echo (2014) Review

There's too much echoing and not enough originality in Earth To Echo. Shot in the ‘found footage’ style, this is no tweenage “Blair Witch Project” and it would be more appropriate to call it a ‘selfie movie’ as the main characters themselves do the filming and are hyper aware of the...

Häxan (1922) Review

Häxan (1922) Review

A Darkly Revolutionary Blend of Documentary, Horror, and the Grotesque. Long before cinema had truly embraced the horror genre as we know it, Häxan burst onto the scene in 1922, blurring the lines between documentary, horror, and surreal nightmare. Directed by Danish filmmaker Benjamin...

The Ambergris Element

The Ambergris Element

Star Trek: The Animated Series S1E13 - The Ambergris Element The Animated Series makes a splash—literally—with The Ambergris Element, an episode that trades starfields for seascapes as the Enterprise crew embarks on an undersea adventure. It’s a bold visual departure, one that takes full...

The Kid Who Would Be King (2019) Review

The Kid Who Would Be King (2019) Review

The Kid Who Would Be King pulls contemporary adventure from the stone of legend. Opening with exactly the same set-up and opening thematic point as “Justice League”, Joe Cornish takes the idea of a country and a world which has lost hope and, with a keen eye for contemporary resonance...