It’s mortality rather than Moriarty troubling Sherlock in the absorbing drama Mr Holmes.

It’s mortality rather than Moriarty who stalks the world’s greatest detective in “Mr. Holmes”, Bill Condon’s quietly engrossing portrait of a legend in decline.

Based on Mitch Cullen’s novel “A Slight Trick Of The Mind”, “Mr. Holmes” finds Sherlock retired and living is seclusion in a remote Sussex farmhouse, caring for his bees and attended only by his housekeeper Mrs Munro and her young son Roger. Despite more than thirty years having passed, Holmes finds himself troubled by Watson’s account of his last case and seeks to set the record straight by recording his own version of events, but his advanced age and failing memory thwart his efforts to recall the events which led him to abruptly retire.

This is Sherlock Holmes as we have never seen him before. Frail, elderly and adrift in a world he no longer recognises or cares for. It’s a bold move to take such a popular character and examine him as he nears his end but the film takes its time to paint an intimate and moving portrait of Holmes’ life in seclusion. Although no longer a detective, Holmes still seeks to pursue his interests, including seeking out potential restoratives to aid his dimming memory. Told in a series of overlapping flashbacks, we learn of Holmes’ recent trip to Japan and the details of his last case.

McKellen delivers a masterful portrayal of an iconic figure, resisting the dying of the light until he feels that he has solved his final case. In the quiet and thoughtful atmosphere of the movie, the power is often in what McKellen chooses to play and not play that gives Holmes such depth and richness. His frailty is all the more shocking thanks to McKellen himself being something of a national treasure: the age make-up is superb, and the physicality of McKellen’s performance is so convincing that we are forced to contemplate the inevitability of the death not only of the character but of the performer.

Thankfully, the flashbacks provide us with some comfort as we get to see a more sprightly Sherlock in his late prime, bristling against the celebrity image of Watson’s literary creation as he takes on the case of a husband whose grieving wife has been behaving strangely. The flashbacks also give us glimpses of Holmes in situations we have rarely seen him in, from the scorched earth of post-war Hiroshima to seeing him sit in a cinema watching a melodramatised version of his own exploits. There’s a gentle theme of the legend versus the man running through “Mr. Holmes” and, in a delicious nod to the past, the black and white movie Holmes is played by Nicholas Rowe, of “Young Sherlock Holmes” fame.

Laura Linney provides a sharp foil for McKellen’s elderly curmudgeon and theirs is a complex relationship which despite the overt resentment and squabbling has a genuine tenderness at its core. Milo Parker, as Roger, is a tremendous find and he gives a terrific performance that manages to more than hold its own against the heavyweight cast he spends the time with. His is the tiny spark of inspiration that brings Sherlock Holmes back into the world and helps him to the greatest discovery of his career.

Veteran director Bill Condon wisely offers no action set pieces or token spectacle, just an intriguing nest of mysteries set against the beautifully photographed Sussex countryside. In a noisy summer of extravagant blockbusters, this is a wonderfully quiet drama. Poignant and powerfully honest, “Mr Holmes” is an absorbing drama about regret and growing old; a study in grey of the twilight of The Great Detective.

mr holmes review
Score 9/10


Hi there! If you enjoyed this post, why not sign up to get new posts sent straight to your inbox?

Sign up to receive a weekly digest of The Craggus' latest posts.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

logo

Related posts

Doctor Who: The Zygon Invasion Review

Doctor Who: The Zygon Invasion Review

The Zygon Invasion gives us more of a trick than a treat For me, this is the first time this series that a first episode of a two-parter hasn’t set the bar particularly high for the conclusion to come. In fact, I really hope this turns the whole convention on...

Norm Of The North (2016) Review

Norm Of The North (2016) Review

Norm Of The North heads South really, really quickly Just in time for “Zootropolis” to crush it under-hoof, “Norm Of The North” lands in cinemas to give us a timely reminder of just how bad animated movies can be. When the arctic (the “North” in this case refers to northern Canada)...

Blithe Spirit (2021) Review

Blithe Spirit (2021) Review

This new production of BLITHE SPIRIT opens on a setting that will look awfully familiar to viewers of AGATHA CHRISTIE’S POIROT, with the iconic house serving as the home of Charles Condomine (Dan Stevens) and his second wife Ruth (Isla Fisher) having appeared in several episodes of the...

Sharknado (2013) Review

Sharknado (2013) Review

Listen here, chum, Sharknado bites. Having finally got round to watching "Sharknado" the day after the UK TV Première (I missed it because I was out watching "Only God Forgives" and we know how that turned out), I wasn't going to review it. After all, what more was there to be said...

X-Men: Dark Phoenix (2019) Review

X-Men: Dark Phoenix (2019) Review

X-Men: Dark Phoenix offers us the chance to dine on ashes while flipping us the bird To the surprise of literally nobody, rising with an entirely unmerited sense of entitlement from the ashes of “X-Men: Apocalypse”, writer/ director Simon Kinberg has only managed to conjure a...

Dinosaur 13 (2014) Review

Dinosaur 13 (2014) Review

Don't tell the Government but I've dug up a review of fossil documentary Prior to 1990, there had only been 12 Tyrannosaurus Rex fossils discovered and none as large and as complete as “Sue”, the T-Rex fossil uncovered during a dig in the badlands of South Dakota. “Dinosaur 13” tells the...

WandaVision Episode 4

WandaVision Episode 4

"We Interrupt This Program" Review With events last week reaching a crisis point in Westview last week, all eyes were on the fourth episode of WANDAVISION to see how the story would be continued. The answer is to crank the metatextual dial up to ‘11’ in WE INTERRUPT THIS PROGRAM and show...

Secret Of The Wings (2012) Review

Secret Of The Wings (2012) Review

I'm forced to rethink Tink after watching Secret Of The Wings I wasn’t particularly generous the first time I encountered one of Disney’s straight-to-video (although released theatrically in the UK) “Tinker Bell” movies. No, I wasn’t enamoured of “The Pirate Fairy” at all. My main...