Everest never really peaks.

There’s always a question mark that hangs over film adaptations of true events, and when it’s the true story of a tragedy, that question is always more pointed. “Everest” struggles with the same problems that “The Impossible” did: what is the point of the movie, apart from to show the tragic suffering and horrific deaths of real people using state of the art special effects?

Baltasar Kormákur’s film is beautifully photographed but doesn’t manage to answer this question. It’s not contextual enough to have documentary value and fails as a drama due to a poor and disjointed script and characterisation thinner than the air at the cruising altitude of a 747. There’s no denying much of it looks spectacular (save for a handful of scenes which are painfully obviously shot on a sound stage and not on location) but it ends up becomes an uncomfortable ‘snuff’ reconstruction: after all, these are ‘real’ people dying in front of you although you’re never invested enough in them to really feel it. What little investment you do have is somewhat diffused once they’re on the mountain because it’s often hard to figure out who is who once they’re all wrapped up in their gratingly ubiquitous North Face gear.

Having assembled a fine cast, the script gives them very little to work with and while some accents veer wildly across the Southern Ocean to the Transvaal rather than New Zealand, the cast do well with what they have to work with.

There’s no heroism, edification or real understanding here of the people involved, just a tragic set of circumstances as experienced mountain climbers make a series of bad decisions and the mountain punishes them for it. A few of the deaths are so perfunctory that they border on absurdist comedy and although the film manages to convey the ferocity and terror of climbing the world’s highest peak, it feels unnecessarily and morbidly voyeuristic to have reconstructed a real tragedy rather than explored the drama and risk of ascending Everest through a fictionalised story.

everest review
Score 6/10


Hi there! If you enjoyed this post, why not sign up to get new posts sent straight to your inbox?

Sign up to receive a weekly digest of The Craggus' latest posts.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

logo

Related posts

Sharknado 4: The 4th Awakens (2016) Review

Sharknado 4: The 4th Awakens (2016) Review

Syfy's great white hope finally jumps the shark Okay. Enough already. This one-joke franchise has more than outstayed its welcome and this flabby, facile and unfocussed fourth outing should (but won’t) mark the end of it. From the tediously laboured “Star Wars”-themed opening...

A Cure For Wellness (2017) Review

A Cure For Wellness (2017) Review

A Cure For Wellness is a story in need of further treatment. There’s no denying Gore Verbinski’s A Cure For Wellness oozes forebodingly Gothic style. It starts conventionally enough, picking out the theme of the callous emptiness of the rat race and a mysterious Swiss ‘wellness’ clinic...

Tiger King: Murder, Mayhem & Madness (2020) Review

Tiger King: Murder, Mayhem & Madness (2020) Review

Netflix plumbs the delusional depths of the secret life of Walter Shitty in artless white trash soap opera Tiger King Imagine, if you will, tigers (and other big cats) were oil and the writers of “Dallas” smoked an ungodly amount of meth before sitting down at their keyboards. The...

Mission: Impossible III (2006) Review

Mission: Impossible III (2006) Review

Abrams brings his trademark mystery box MacGuffinry to Mission: Impossible. The cold open is cruel. Intimate, restrained, but cruel. Ethan Hunt, bound to a chair, watches the woman he loves about to be executed while a man with the face of a disapproving accountant calmly counts to ten...

Shark Swarm (2008) Review

Shark Swarm (2008) Review

Armand Assante chews the scenery in Shark Swarm Too short to be a miniseries but too long, really, to be a movie, this Hallmark production weighs in at a whale shark-esque two hours and forty minutes, which is a long time to endure a bad shark movie, so it’s a good thing "Shark...

The Alienist Season Review

The Alienist Season Review

Mister X says in The Alienist, no-one can hear you yawn. It’s the late nineteenth century in New York and delinquent children are starting to go missing. Future President and newly appointed Police Commissioner Theodore Roosevelt (Brian Geraghty )contacts criminal psychologist Dr Laszlo...

Jay And Silent Bob Reboot (2019) Review

Jay And Silent Bob Reboot (2019) Review

Across The View Askewniverse:Jay And Silent Bob Reboot There’s little point in denying that “Jay And Silent Bob Reboot” is Smith’s most self-referential work to date. If “Jay And Silent Bob Strike Back” was Smith’s first greatest hits album, this is the remastered re-release with all the...

Thanksgiving (2023) Review

Thanksgiving (2023) Review

I don't mean to sound ungrateful, but... Director Eli Roth sharpens his cinematic vision to the point where it's ready to carve up the holiday turkey, slicing into the most quintessentially American holiday outside of the 4th of July with a gleeful brutality that only he can deliver. In...

1 Comment
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Hammy Reviews
9 years ago

Great cinematography, but poor characterisation and script!!!