Sherlock: The Abominable Bride (2016) Review

*SPOILERS*

The Abominable Bride

With the surprising end to Season 3, viewers were excited to see where the BBC’s “Sherlock” would go next and, true to form, Steven Moffat and Mark Gatiss trolled everyone by announcing that the forthcoming special – The Abominable Bride – would take place in the period for which Holmes is most famously known: the 19th Century – a literal world away from the series’ contemporary roots.

The clash of time zones is threaded throughout the story, especially in the uncomfortably topical opening of the mystery featuring a crazy loner with a gun shooting into the street. Of course, this is merely the beginning of another impossible mystery for Holmes to unravel as the shooter turns out to be a woman who very publicly commits suicide dressed in her wedding dress only to apparently rise from the grave and murder her husband. Months later, the phantasmagorical bride reappears to kill again, leading Holmes to uncover a bridal killing spree which rivals Beatrix Kiddo’s rampage in “Kill Bill”.

Unfortunately, the period trappings are a constant niggling distraction from the key question on the viewer’s mind, which is how this possible connects to the series we know and love. It’s a shame too because leaving aside the usual series, this really is a top-notch marriage of cast and lovingly recreated Victoriana (there’s a trip to Limehouse which makes you yearn for the possibility for “Doctor Who” to somehow remake “The Talons Of Weng-Chiang” with the same money and care lavished on it).

Everybody in the cast gets to play dress-up, even if it gets a bit “Blackadder”-ish in the Morgue. Cumberbatch and Freeman are, if such a thing is possible, even better as Holmes and Watson in period garb. Una Stubbs’ Mrs Hudson and Rupert Graves’ Lestrade especially seem more buffoonish and comedic than their modern day counterparts and it seems that, regardless of the setting, it Amanda Abbington’s Mary Watson is destined to play the series’ version of the plot moving/ problem solving sonic screwdriver. Gatiss has tremendous fun as the morbidly obese Mycroft but was also the character which tipped the episode’s main conceit with a few choice anachronistic remarks peppered in amongst the dialogue. Director Douglas Mackinnon also enjoys himself transposing the series’ usual visual flourishes to their 19th century counterparts.

The eventual resolution of the mystery of “The Abominable Bride”, in reality, a cadre of hyper militant suffragettes with decidedly KKK-influenced wardrobe choices (another nod to the original Holmes Story ‘The Five Orange Pips’) is somewhat lost amidst the narrative game of three-card Monte as Gatiss and Moffat seek to perpetuate the playful conceit of which era is real? The past or the present? A great deal is left teased for the forthcoming fourth season of “Sherlock” but I was left pondering a more interesting question: have Moffat and Gatiss become the first people to successfully create a spin-off of their own show from itself? I have to confess, I’d happily watch new adventures of this Holmes and Watson is either timeframe.

Score 8

8/10 

logo

Related posts

Paddington 2 (2017) is almost too delightful to bear.

Paddington 2 (2017) is almost too delightful to bear.


Paddington 2 (2017) is almost too delightful to bear.

With the original having been an unexpected delight, anticipation for “Paddington 2” was sky-high. Could the little bear from Peru pull off the ‘difficult’ second movie? The answer is an unqualified ‘yes’.Determined to get his Aunt Lucy a special present for her 100th birthday, Paddington (Ben...

The Great Wall (2017) Review

The Great Wall (2017) Review


The Great Wall (2017) Review

“The Great Wall” is an epic Chinese fantasy adventure film unfortunately compromised by the token addition of a pair of western actors in an attempt to increase its box office potential.Set in the time of the Song Dynasty, the Great Wall Of China is one of the wonders of the world, but...

Moana (2016) Review

Moana (2016) Review


Moana (2016) Review

Disney’s new golden age shows no signs of slowing down as they cap an amazing animated year with the breezy, tropical feel good musical “Moana”.Drawing on Polynesian mythology, “Moana” tells the story of a young girl who longs to leave her island and explore the oceans. Encouraged by...

Gone Girl (2014) Review

Gone Girl (2014) Review


Gone Girl (2014) Review

It’s nearly impossible to discuss "Gone Girl" without veering into spoiler territory so – reluctantly – I’m going to have to put up a precautionary *SPOILER WARNING* even though I’ll try and be as oblique as possible.When Nick Dunne (Ben Affleck) returns home to find his home in...