Making A Murderer is must-be-seen-to-be-believed TV.

Have you watched Netflix’s “Making A Murderer”? Sure you have, or you’re about to, or you’re part of the way through. No, wait – scratch that. Nobody‘s ‘part of the way through’ “Making A Murderer”. You’re either binge-watching it, or you’ve finished it and are still trying to pick your jaw up off the floor.

If you have Netflix, you will know that they are constantly bringing out excellent shows. If you don’t have Netflix, you need to take a look and get on it. You’re seriously missing out otherwise! Netflix have struck original programming gold again, and this time it’s fact, not fiction that has subscribers promising themselves ‘just one more episode’ before they sleep/ work/ eat/ bathe/ interact with another human being.

The ten-part documentary series tells the true story of Steven Avery, a native of Manitowoc, Wisconsin who was imprisoned for eighteen years for a crime he did not commit only to be eventually released and almost immediately implicated, charged and tried for murder while continually maintaining his innocence.

Filmed over the course of ten years, as events unfolded, “Making A Murderer” benefits from the same sense of authenticity that the long-form filming imbued “Boyhood” with but this is no gentle coming of age drama. It’s an unremittingly gripping, endlessly fascinating and masterfully curated story of the prosecution of a crime-riddled with inconsistencies, allegations of corruption and crooked practices and some breath-taking twists, turns and outcomes.

Until you’ve started watching it, it’s hard to really understand just how utterly compelling the story is. It has everything you could want from a courtroom drama – a terrible crime, a questionable accused, family loyalty, betrayals, noble lawyers, slimy prosecutors, crooked cops, shady investigators, red herrings, overlooked potential suspects, contradictory evidence and utterly contemptible villains. Oh, and the victim, who – tellingly – doesn’t occupy much of the documentary because she, Teresa Halbach, didn’t seem to concern the prosecution anywhere near as much as nailing Steven Avery for the crime did.

Responsible for creating a legion of armchair detectives and couch-based criminal justice experts, the very nature of the events being presented remind you that the perception of the facts can easily be manipulated by skilful and wilful selectivity. Do I believe Steven Avery is guilty? Whether I do or not (I’m not declaring for fear of spoilers), the opinion I formed was based on the evidence I was presented with. And even while watching and – occasionally – yelling at the TV, I was aware that what I was being presented with was selected for me by the documentary makers, Moira Demos and Laura Ricciardi. Both in the subject and in execution, “Making A Murderer” demonstrates just how powerfully facts and opinions can be manipulated and manufactured. Absolute truth is an impossibility as we’re allowed to see a broken system through a fractured lens.

A quick Google search of the case (absolutely forbidden while we were watching!) brings up a few aspects which were omitted from the documentary, throwing additional light on some facets of the case but I understand the need to do that. The documentary is ten hours long, covering a trial that ran for weeks and events which covered years. In saying that, even after reading up on the available details of the case, there doesn’t seem to be too much that was left out, and nothing I’ve heard or read since watching it has swayed my own verdict, suggesting the documentary filmmakers got the balance just about right.

“Making A Murderer” is fantastic, engrossing entertainment – and it is first and foremost an entertainment product – but like the best entertainment, it raises important issues in a thought-provoking and fascinating way. Its unique intensity comes from the fact it not only deals with a true story but one that is still going on to this day and the dangers of the abuse of power and procedure by the authorities and institutions involved have ramifications far beyond the limits of this one fascinating case.

making a murderer review
Score 9/10


Hi there! If you enjoyed this post, why not sign up to get new posts sent straight to your inbox?

Sign up to receive a weekly digest of The Craggus' latest posts.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

logo

Related posts

The Reef (2010) Review

The Reef (2010) Review

The Reef brings real sharks and real terror to Shark Weak 2 The thing I love about sharksploitation movies is they’re generally fun. Fun is a big part of the appeal, even when – or maybe especially when – they’re bad. “The Reef” is not a bad movie, but it's also definitely not a...

The Legend Of The 7 Golden Vampires (1974) Review

The Legend Of The 7 Golden Vampires (1974) Review

The Legend Of The 7 Golden Vampires could do with a dash of Monkey Magic Devoid of their Dracula, Hammer House Of Horror cast around for something else to stake their vampire franchise to. One can only imagine that the radio was playing in writer Don Houghton’s Bray Studios office as he...

Dracula (1979) Review

Dracula (1979) Review

He's bringing sexy Drac. Back in 1979, Universal dusted off its back catalogue and made plans to make a feature film featuring Dracula for the first time since 1948. And they didn’t even think to wrap a whole shared universe around it, dark or otherwise. Ah, those were the...

The Death Of “Superman Lives”: What Happened? (2015) Review

The Death Of "Superman Lives": What Happened? (2015) Review

Studios who don't study history are doomed to repeat it Made by fan boys but not just for fanboys (full disclosure: I contributed to the Kickstarter for this), Jon Schnepp’s documentary "The Death Of Superman Lives" not only lifts the lid on one of cinema’s most...

Into The Forest I Go

Into The Forest I Go

Sometimes Star Trek: Discovery can't see the wood for the trees. *SPOILERS* Apologies for the delay in getting this "Into The Forest I Go" review out there, but as I was writing, it started out as one thing and sort became something else as I went along. Not unlike “Star Trek...

The Mummy (2017) Review

The Mummy (2017) Review

It'll take more than a few bandages to fix what ails The Mummy Released in the UK the same day another leader saw plans to increase her power and turn the world to her will falter, “The Mummy” suggests Universal’s “Dark Universe” gambit will meet a similarly ignominious fate...

Split (2017) Review

Split (2017) Review

Split is, ironically, a slyly connective work from M Night Shyamalan Yet another director seemingly completing his comeback, “Split” sees M Night Shyamalan building on the momentum of "The Visit" and nearing a return to his best form as he once again explores the boundary between...

Trance (2013) Review

Trance (2013) Review

"Trance" is an edgy, complex and stylish psychological thriller with a twisty turny plot that will keep you on the edge of your seat. Or at least it wants to be, and you know what? I think we should let it, because it tries so very, very hard. So hard.