Beeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeep. . . . That’s not a flatline, that’s me swearing in frustration at this film

Nineties with a capital 9, stripped of the rose-coloured shroud of nostalgia, Joel Schumacher’s morbid thriller emphasises the ‘flat’ in “Flatliners”.

Inspired by the near-death experiences of patients, a  group of brilliant, ambitious medical students decide to probe beyond the veil to establish empirically what happens when you die. But as each of them becomes haunted by what they saw, they must find a way to make peace with their experiences.

Stuffed with Brat Pack actors, Schumacher brings the same campy gothic aesthetic to “Flatliners” that he would later dial all the way up to 11 in “Batman & Robin”. Unfortunately, the ludicrously grandiose set design and general post-industrial atmosphere simply serve to undermine any sense of realism whatsoever, leaving the flights of fantasy with nothing to ground them. Everything is lit with the subtlety of a sledgehammer in stark orange or bright blue to give you a ready indicator as to whether something good or bad is happening, which is handy because your attention will wander as much as the plot does. Even if you’re not paying attention, though, you’ll still notice some of the clumsiest on screen set adjustments to accommodate the forthcoming camera movement you’ll ever see.

Essentially a high-concept morality play about atoning for past (or sometimes present) sins, it’s all terribly vague and vaguely terrible. Kiefer Sutherland – who despite being a poor medical student apparently lives in a giant mansion from a high-class fragrance commercial – hides possibly the worst secret of the bunch. But then again they’re all phenomenally bad scientists, withholding vital information from each other, making a mockery of the pretence they’re invested in scientific research rather than a low-wattage Twilight Zone clip show. Despite raising some interesting philosophical, metaphysical and theological questions, the film doesn’t care to address them at all, preferring to focus on the banal, small stories of the characters.

All flash and very little bang, the only flatline that sticks in the mind was my level of interest in the self-indulgent narcissistic guilt trips of these unlikeable characters, except for Sutherland’s Norman, whose level of guilt is so far removed from the context of the others that his ultimate redemption feels grotesque. If people are calling the new remake a disappointment, I can’t help but wonder if they’re setting the original’s bar low enough?

flatliners review
Score 4/10
logo

Related posts

Penguins Of Madagascar (2014) Review

Penguins Of Madagascar (2014) Review

Should you p-p-p-pick up a ticket for Penguins Of Madagascar? Spin-offs, eh? It seems like a sure thing: take a popular supporting character and give them own fully-fledged adventure but there can be hidden pitfalls. As the swaggering, cocky never-say-die plot drivers (and frequent deus...

Hulk (2003) Review

Hulk (2003) Review

Don't remake it angry, you won't like it when you're angry Not to be corny, but today marks the 15th anniversary of the not-so-jolly green giant’s big screen debut, Ang Lee’s underappreciated “Hulk”. It also probably marks at least ten years since I last watched it and I’d always...

Planet Hulk (2009) Review

Planet Hulk (2009) Review

We've come to our Craggnarok journey's end. The Road To Ragnarok Part 3: Planet Hulk Our Road to Ragnarok concludes with an adventure which doesn’t feature Thor but still provides a great deal of material and inspiration for the forthcoming MCU movie: “Planet Hulk”. With the...

The Comey Rule (2020) Review

The Comey Rule (2020) Review

The only thing that was necessary for the triumph of evil was for a good man to do the 'right' thing. “The Comey Rule”, based on the memoirs of the ex-head of the FBI, James Comey, splits very clearly into two eras: BE, Before the Election – and AE. Detailing the events and...

House Of Frankenstein (1944) Review

House Of Frankenstein (1944) Review

Whose house? Frank's house! I said whose house? House Of Frankenstein The “Infinity War” of its day, “House Of Frankenstein” – also featuring Boris Karloff’s very last role in the Universal Monster Universe – brought together the tangled continuities of their “Frankenstein” “Wolf Man”...

All Of Us Strangers (2024) Review

All Of Us Strangers (2024) Review

Andrew Scott and Paul Mescal lead a hauntingly poignant meditation on grief. Some films slip into the soul so quietly that you only realise their full weight when the credits are rolling, and All of Us Strangers is one of them. Andrew Haigh has crafted something extraordinary - a film...

Late Night (2019) Review

Late Night (2019) Review

Late Night wants you to stay tuned for these important messages. Over the past couple of years, I’ve gotten more and more into American Late Night talk shows. Not the vainglorious onanism of James Corden but the biting satire of the more political shows like “The Late Show With Stephen...

Alita: Battle Angel (2019) Review

Alita: Battle Angel (2019) Review

Alita: Battle Angel slices, dices and occasionally surprises Knowing nothing of the original Manga on which it’s based (the closest I can claim is that I quite enjoy the 2009 animated movie “Astro Boy”, which shares a surprising amount of story with this film), “Alita: Battle...