Caine and Kingsley subvert Sherlock in a delightful romp

Realweegiemidget Reviews is celebrating Michael Caine’s 85th birthday with a Marvellous Michael Caine Blogathon and I’ve used it as an excuse to revisit one of my favourite comfort movies: “Without A Clue”

Dr John Watson (Ben Kingsley) uses his keen analytical mind and powers of observation to solve crimes but, seeking not to jeopardize his chances of landing a job at a prestigious hospital, he invents the figure of Sherlock Holmes to take the credit. But when public demand grows for Holmes to appear in the flesh, Watson hires unemployed actor Reginald Kincaid (Michael Caine) to play the part.

There’s a delightfully gentle elegance to “Without A Clue” and despite its comedic twist it takes great pains to be authentically Sherlockian and keeping with the period. It helps that the two screenwriters, Gary Murphy and Larry Strawther are devoted Sherlockians, steeped in the lore of the greatest fictional detective of all time. The twist of reversing the roles and placing Watson at the cutting investigative edge is a marvellous conceit, allowing the film to have tremendous fun subverting the stereotypes and simultaneously archly commenting of the real life struggles of author Sir Arthur Conan Doyle to escape and move beyond his most famous literary creation.

Kinglsey cuts a dashing, debonair figure as Dr Watson, the would-be ‘Crime Doctor’ and its thanks to his warm and impish chemistry with Caine that the film succeeds so spectacularly. Caine gets the lion’s share of the larks, clearly having the time of his life hamming it up as the wannabe raconteur and master thespian and the ease at which Caine manages to play the dual role within a role is a testament to how skilled and often underrated an actor he is.

The supporting cast is fun too, with Jeffrey Jones as Lestrade, Lysette Anthony Leslie Giles and Paul Freeman (“Raiders Of The Lost Ark”) as a wonderfully Puckish Professor Moriarty. There are plenty of nods to the official Holmes canon but the film’s secret weapon is that the plot itself, while played for comedy as expertly as Holmes himself bows his violin, feels like a genuine ‘lost’ Conan Doyle adventure and would work terrifically as a straight Sherlock Holmes adventure.

Sadly, this was their one and only outing as Holmes and Watson, but Caine and Kingsley are so good you wish this had been the start of a long franchise. Happy Birthday, Sir Michael – and thank you for “Without A Clue”.

without a clue review
Score 8/10
logo

Related posts

I, Frankenstein (2014) Review

I, Frankenstein (2014) Review

I feel a need to dig out my pitchfork after watching I, Frankenstein. ‘From the producers of Underworld’ proclaims the poster proudly, and boy – they aren’t kidding. It should really read: ‘From the producers of Underworld who used Ctrl+H to replace Werewolves with Gargoyles and Vampires...

How To Train Your Dragon (2025) Review

How To Train Your Dragon (2025) Review

How to reskin your franchise. There’s a line in Marvel’s Avengers, where Steve Rogers and Tony Stark are arguing, and Stark tells Captain America that “everything special about you came out of a bottle”. Stark is, as he will come to learn, wrong but it’s a line that comes to mind every...

The Witches (1990) Review

The Witches (1990) Review

Fall under the spell of Nicolas Roeg's The Witches Much as Ian Fleming did with “Dr. No”, Roald Dhal dismissed the film version of his novel “The Witches” as ‘utterly appalling’ and much like Fleming was, he’s was being far too harsh. When Luke’s parents are killed in a car accident...

Frank (2014) Review

Frank (2014) Review

Stick this Frank review in your pipe and smoke it! Whimsical, quirky and sometimes just downright weird, “Frank” is a delightfully offbeat comedy-drama from Irish director Lenny Abrahamson. Starring Domhnall Gleeson, Michael Fassbender, Maggie Gyllenhaal and Scoot McNairy, it tells the...

The Interview (2015) Review

The Interview (2015) Review

Is there really no such thing as bad publicity? It’s been a couple of months now since the so called Guardians Of Peace (allegedly backed by North Korea) demanding the takedown of “The Interview”.  After Sony’s corporate flip flopping over the release, it finally arrives in the UK...

National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation (1989) Review

National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation (1989) Review

Idyllic family holidays are what's roasting on an open fire in National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation. Sweeter and more whimsical than its two bawdy predecessors, “National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation” sees the long-suffering Griswald family actually staying put for once while the chaos...

American Made (2017) Review

American Made (2017) Review

The CIA activates Cruise control. If you thought off-the-books, quasi-legal internecine government shenanigans were a practice brought to the White House by a tangerine reality TV buffoon, wait until you get a load of AMERICAN MADE and find out what was going on the last time a former...

Van Helsing (2004) Review

Van Helsing (2004) Review

Hugh Jackman is a steampunk James Bond, hunting public domain bad guys for the Vatican in muddled and messy action horror Van Helsing Universal have been trying to resurrect their Dark Universe for a lot longer than you may think. Back in 2004, emboldened by the quick one-two hits of...

2 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Realweegiemidget Reviews

Lovely review of this movie- you can tell its a fave, thanks for joining my blogathon after my gentle nudge and with such a lovely tribute.

Silver Screenings
7 years ago

What a terrific premise for this film! Brilliant. I never would have thought of it.