You Were Never Really Here offers a powerful and violent meditation on PTSD.

Provocative, dark, disturbing and brutally violent, “You Were Never Really Here” envelops you in the dissociated world of Joe, a traumatized veteran who tracks down missing children for a living. When a routine job spirals out of control, Joe finds himself caught up in a conspiracy of violence and murder, spinning out of control and fracturing his fragile grip on reality. It’s through this fractured lens that director/ screenwriter Lynne Ramsay explores a sordid, decadent, corrupt world of sex trafficking, money, power and revenge.

Comparisons to “Taxi Driver” are inevitable but also sell this film short. There’s a trippy, dream-like quality to the whole film and Joe’s damaged psyche becomes the unreliable narrator around which our perceptions are forced to navigate. Flitting between fantasy and reality, there’s an abundance of riches on offer for you to assemble the narrative that works best for you. There are several key turning points in the film and each on their own could be leading Joe to his damnation or salvation, depending on your point of view.

Joaquin Phoenix is incredible, wringing every last drop of emotional truth from Joe’s shattered existence. Flashes of dark humour briefly illuminate the darkness of the subtext, dripping with Oedipal undertones and corrupted versions of familial love. The cinematography is frequently stunning and while there’s a superficial impression that Joe’s PTSD has conveyed a sort of superpower of relentless fearlessness, it’s clear that every new atrocity further shatters a life lived as if made entirely from broken glass.

Edgy, experimental and brutal and yet somehow darkly poetic, “You Were Never Really Here” fulfils the ambiguous promise of its title in a beautifully shot, abstruse slow-burn psychological revenge thriller.

You were never really here review
Score 7/10
logo

Related posts

Killer Rack (2015) Review

Killer Rack (2015) Review

Killer Rack is a low-brow high-concept horror-comedy that's a total bust. Proving I’ve a somewhat Pavlovian respone to notificaions from Letterboxd, I was notified that KILLER RACK was now available on Prime Video and immediately watched it. It turned out that notification was a...

Gifted (2017) Review

Gifted (2017) Review

Chris Evans and Mckenna Grace help Gifted realise its potential. Perhaps stung by the unfairly hostile reception to his “Amazing Spider-Man” movies, Marc Webb returns to cinemas with “Gifted”, a decidedly smaller scale and more intimate movie about a child genius. Frank (Chris Evans)...

Tarzan (2014) Review

Tarzan (2014) Review

It’s a swing and a miss for the King of the Jungle. This new motion-capture animated take on the Tarzan legend comes courtesy of German animation studio Ambient Entertainment GmbH. Set in an Uncanny Valley somewhere in Africa, it tells an updated version of the story of a young boy...

Red Sparrow (2018) Review

Red Sparrow (2018) Review

Red Sparrow turns out to be little more than a lukewarm Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Psyche! Disney and Marvel can at least rest easy: “Red Sparrow” certainly isn’t the “Black Widow” solo movie by another name its marketing might have initially suggested. Instead, it’s something of a...

Companion (2025) Review

Companion (2025) Review

Hey Siri - show me a cautionary tale of tech bro entitlement. Companion begins with the kind of setup that feels both familiar and quietly ominous: a lakeside retreat, a close circle of friends, and something just… slightly off. What follows isn’t so much a slow-burn thriller as a...

The Nice Guys (2016) Review

The Nice Guys (2016) Review

The Nice Guys definitely won't finish last when I list my favourite films of the year. Shane Black’s sincerely affectionate love letter to “The Rockford Files” and the seventies in general, “The Nice Guys” is another helping of knowingly comic crime capers, powered by the amiably gruff...

1 Comment
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Chris
7 years ago

As a fan of Ramsay and Phoenix I might check this one out at some point. I don’t think it can top Taxi Driver though which is favorite of mine