Mister X says in The Alienist, no-one can hear you yawn.

It’s the late nineteenth century in New York and delinquent children are starting to go missing. Future President and newly appointed Police Commissioner Theodore Roosevelt (Brian Geraghty )contacts criminal psychologist Dr Laszlo Kreizler (Daniel Brühl), the titular Alienist, and illustrator John Moore (Luke Evans) for help to solve the case. When Dr Keizler and Mr Moore realise that the job is too big for two people they enlist Commissioner Roosevelt’s secretary Miss Howard (Dakota Fanning), who Mr Moore has a previous romantic history with, and Police Officers Lucius and Marcus Isaacson to help with the investigation.

During their enquiries, the team uncover the full gruesome extent of the abductions, the reasoning for them along with a conspiracy amongst high ranking officials and members of high society to keep the investigation and the main suspect secret.

I had high hopes for The Alienist as it was born out of several impressive creative talents, namely Cary Fukunaga (True Detective) and Eric Roth (Munich). What we get is a lavishly recreated world but one that isn’t quite sure of its axis. Is it an exploration of how people in a position of power exploit the poor and disadvantaged, or of what men are capable of based on the world they live in and experience? Neither is clear.

That’s not to say that this is a good show, as it is jam packed with superb performances from Daniel Brühl, Luke Evans and Dakota Fanning although Brian Geraghty as the future POTUS is by far the stand out when he’s on screen but halfway through what appears to be a pretty standard period detective show, just as it’s starting to find its feet there’s a twist that feels pointless and misguided, completely shifting the show’s direction and pace.

With the twist we are introduced to something far more menacing in its build-up than its execution that unfortunately falls flat in the final reveal and leaves you thinking ‘was that it?’. It’s a real shame as there’s clearly a great premise locked within the shows shell but maybe the time has passed for this type of story. Had “The Alienist” been released five years ago it would be hailed as a masterpiece but it doesn’t forge into any new territory that shows like “Ripper Street” and “Sherlock” haven’t already done. For that reason, a lot of it feels stale.

The ‘will they won’t they?’ side plot between John Moore and Sara Howard feels pointless and undermines Dakota Fanning’s character’s role as a headstrong female struggling for credibility in a male-dominated Police force, but my biggest gripe is that every dramatic scene is proceeded by five seconds of black screen. I’m presuming that this is because it was originally broadcast in the US on TNT and that these were to facilitate ad breaks, but if Netflix wants to keep presenting bought-in series as ‘Netflix Originals’ they would do well to judiciously edit these kinds of things out. Watching it on an iPad is incredibly infuriating.

Less than the sum of its parts and feeling past its sell-by date, “The Alienist” ends up alienating the very viewers it needs to impress. Watch this if you liked: “Ripper Street”, “From Hell”, “Sherlock”, “Se7en”

the alienist review
Score 5/10


Hi there! If you enjoyed this post, why not sign up to get new posts sent straight to your inbox?

Sign up to receive a weekly digest of The Craggus' latest posts.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

logo

Related posts

Abigail (2024) Review

Abigail (2024) Review

You'll want to decline any invitation to this Abigail's party Leaping onto screens with the grace of a prima ballerina and the grand guignol of a slaughterhouse, Abigail continues Universal’s recent trend of discretely rebooting their classic monster movies in innovative and...

My Daughter’s Doctor

My Daughter's Doctor

My Daughter's Doctor As I write this, we are mere minutes away from finding out who will become the sixteenth actor to portray Doctor Who in the Time Lord's fifteenth incarnation: The 13th Doctor is nigh (not Nighy, although that would be kind of awesome). I've always held to the...

Shaun The Sheep Movie (2015) Review

Shaun The Sheep Movie (2015) Review

The title grammar may be baaaad but Shaun The Sheep Movie isn't the black sheep of the Aardman movies It’s unlikely the target audience of the latest family-friendly stop-motion feature from Aardman will be as bothered by the grammar of the title as I am (not The Shaun The Sheep...

Death Of A Unicorn (2025) Review

Death Of A Unicorn (2025) Review

A creature feature satire with a point. Death Of A Unicorn begins, as many good creature features should, with something unexpected in the middle of the forest road. Only this time, it’s not a raccoon or an unfortunate hitchhiker - it’s a unicorn. A pristine, pastel-hued, literally...

The First Purge (2018) Review

The First Purge (2018) Review

The First Purge feels like the Snyder Cut of Childish Gambino's "This Is America" What better viewing choice on the 4th of July than the latest instalment in the satirical horror series, one that goes back to the beginning and commemorates the very start of the decline of the land...

Godzilla: King Of The Monsters (2019) Review

Godzilla: King Of The Monsters (2019) Review

They mostly come out in murky light. Mostly. Typical. You wait five years for a monster to show up and then four come at once. Following the events of “Godzilla”, secretive megacryptid management organisation Monarch has been working diligently to discover, catalogue and contain...

WandaVision Episode 4

WandaVision Episode 4

"We Interrupt This Program" Review With events last week reaching a crisis point in Westview last week, all eyes were on the fourth episode of WANDAVISION to see how the story would be continued. The answer is to crank the metatextual dial up to ‘11’ in WE INTERRUPT THIS PROGRAM and show...

Spooks: The Greater Good (2015) Review

Spooks: The Greater Good (2015) Review

Spooks: The Greater Good isn't great, but it's pretty good if you were a fan of the TV show Swapping Black Crows for Black Ops, Kit Harrington finds he still knows nothing as he runs around London trying to unravel Harry Pearce's latest Gordian knot of conspiracy and double crosses...