Cinema continues to be barren ground for the seeding of new franchises

Despite an impeccable cast and an intriguing premise, “Mortal Engines” looks likely to follow in the tracks of “His Dark Materials” adaptation “The Golden Compass” and fail to thrive in the cinematic environment. It’s a shame, too, but it underlines the difficulties faced when adapting epic fantasy book series to the cinema, especially in the era of  TV streaming.

In a post-apocalyptic wasteland where city-states roam the land, scavenging and consuming each other to survive, London is a fearsome apex predator but Thaddeus Valentine (Hugo Weaving) plots for more. He has his eyes on The Wall and the riches of the Anti-Traction League which lie beyond and will stop at nothing to achieve his goals. Meanwhile, Hester Shaw (Hera Hilmer) has plotted and schemed her way onto London with only one aim: kill Valentine and avenge her mother’s murder.

It’s a handsome and well-realised adaptation of the book, with gorgeous steampunk visuals and solid performances from all involved but in the process of adapting the novel to a reasonably lean (these days) two-hour movie, much of the novel’s insightful satire and social commentary has been lost. The movie finds itself having to hurry through the story from one plot point or set piece to the next one that it never gets the chance to really breathe before it rushes forward to its next target.

It’s a thrilling ride, but the texture and depth of the tale are sacrificed for cinematic expediency. The world-building is still there if you’ve an eye and ear for it, but it’s far too dependent on the audience being familiar with the books to work on its own merits. The subtextual critique of unsustainable consumption and the indictment of Darwinian economic exploitation and the class system which rigidly reinforces the inequities necessary for its own survival are barely touched on in the course of the film and characters which are hugely significant to the overall story, such as Shrike (Stephen Lang) are reduced to little more than a cameo boogeyman.

Without this narrative heft, it can be a little too easy to dismiss this as a throwaway steampunk fantasy, a goofy tale of a Big Trak city but the series really opens out after the first book and becomes so much more. It looks unlikely that we’ll get to see any more of this story on the big screen and it may be some time before its picked up by one of the streaming services to be given the long-form TV series treatment it needs to reach its full potential and the audience it deserves. In the meantime, read the books. I promise you won’t be disappointed.

mortal engines review
Score 6/10
logo

Related posts

Treehouse Of Horror XX

Treehouse Of Horror XX

2009's Treehouse Of Horror XX opens in classic Horror fashion as the Universal Monsters coming to life for Halloween. It's funny that they're seen as old hat so they need to get themselves some modern costumes, and funnier still when their various brides turn up to ruin the...

Megalopolis (2024) Review

Megalopolis (2024) Review

Megalopolis is undeniably a work of art, but it's not a coherent movie. I have a soft spot for vainglorious, big-swing sci-fi, the kind of ambitious projects that aim for the stars even if they end up face-planting back to Earth. Megalopolis is Francis Ford Coppola's contribution to this...

Hellboy (2004) Review

Hellboy (2004) Review

Hellboy smashes his way into the superhero cinematic pantheon. In 2004, Hellboy was summoned to the big screen under the inspired direction of Guillermo del Toro, bringing Mike Mignola’s beloved comic book creation to life with a perfect blend of dark fantasy, pulpy action, and a...

Craggus’ Trek Trek Phase II Vol 6

Craggus' Trek Trek Phase II Vol 6

You'll fall head over heels for Craggus' Trek Trek Phase II Vol 6! Craggus Trek Trek Phase II Vol 6 brings us, mercifully, to the end of season 2 although it saved the worst for last. Star Trek The Next Generation S1E16: Q Who Q is back and Guinan...

Coneheads (1993) Review

Coneheads (1993) Review

Consuming mass quantities of Coneheads is highly recommended. When I first discovered CONEHEADS (1993), I was entirely ignorant of its origins as a recurring SATURDAY NIGHT LIVE sketch whose origins were almost as old as I was. Part of the short-lived 1990s boom of SNL sketch-based...

The Beastmaster (1982) Review

The Beastmaster (1982) Review

All hail the real Tiger King! "The Beastmaster" is one of the rarer films in my Comfort Movie pantheon in that I loved it so much, I was never willing to risk even the slightest sliver of my affection for it by watching either of the belated sequels or the TV spin-off which I only...

Alien Shark (2022) Review

Alien Shark (2022) Review

In watching bad shark movies, no one can hear you scream The bad shark movie hall of fame is crammed to the gills with flotsam, jetsam and plain old garbage but Alien Shark stakes a strong claim to be one of the most bizarre and bewildering titles of all. It defies logic, gravity...

Twister (1996) Review

Twister (1996) Review

This is one movie that'll spin you right round, baby Hold on to your hats, folks, because Twister is the movie that whipped up a storm of thrills and spills, leaving audiences breathless back in 1996. Helen Hunt starred as tenacious storm chaser Jo Harding, whose estranged husband...