Mary Poppins Returns is an exercise in Lucasian poetry.

Assembled more like one of Disney’s current ‘live action’ adaptations of their animated back catalogue than a genuine sequel to the 1964 original, “Mary Poppins Returns” brings back cinema’s premiere Nanny to answer another Banks crisis.

In Depression-era London, a now-grown Jane (Emily Mortimer) and Michael Banks (Ben Wishaw), along with Michael’s three children, face eviction from their family home, having fallen behind on the payments to the Bank. Enter Mary Poppins (Emily Blunt), back to help out and put the Banks family back on the right track with the help of her lamplighter friend Jack (Lin-Manuel Miranda) and an assortment of colourful musical numbers.

George Lucas once claimed that the many repetitive instances in the Star Wars prequel trilogy were deliberate ‘poetry’, rhyming with the original trilogy and so it is with this second Mary Poppins film. Having soothed its corporate conscience with “Saving Mr Banks”, Disney returns to the works of P L Travers to produce a checkbox musical which follows the template of the first movie to a fault. Each song in this new one has a counterpart in the original although only time will tell whether any of the new crop will have the same longevity as “Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious”. It’s also similar to the original in that it’s a little meandering, a little overlong and a lot overindulgent. There are too many extraneous musical numbers which add nothing to the plot which wouldn’t be a problem if the plot wasn’t so threadbare and inadequate. The villain’s motivations are never really properly articulated and the answer to the Banks’ woes is obvious to everyone except them apparently, not that it matters because everything is resolved with a Van Dyke ex machina cameo at the end.

Despite the uneven and indulgent script, the cast lift it up. Emily Blunt makes for a wonderful Mary Poppins, although slightly primmer yet more archly mischievous than Julie Andrews’ air of timeless wisdom. She’s matched by Miranda’s likeable Jack (of-all-trades) and the likes of Julie Walters, Ben Wishaw and Emily Mortimer although Colin Firth is curiously underserved by the script. There’s also an oddly conspicuous cameo towards the end featuring Angela Landsbury which was clearly intended for Julie Andrews (who passed on the role in order to voice the Karathen in “Aquaman” instead), neatly reversing the switch which occurred during the making of “Bedknobs And Broomsticks”.

Better than the soulless cash-grab some dismissed it as, but nowhere near as iconic as the original (but was it ever fair to expect it to be?) “Mary Poppins Returns” is still polished family entertainment, but if it’s going to restart the series it’ll need to take the risk of doing something new when “Mary Poppins Forever” comes around.

mary poppins returns review
Score 7/10


Hi there! If you enjoyed this post, why not sign up to get new posts sent straight to your inbox?

Sign up to receive a weekly digest of The Craggus' latest posts.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

logo

Related posts

Teen Titans Go! To The Movies (2018) Review

Teen Titans Go! To The Movies (2018) Review

Teen Titans Go! To The Movies slaaaaaaaays As a fan of the original Teen Titans animated series, I was deeply sceptical of “Teen Titans Go!” when it first aired. Silly, childish and cutesy, it seemed like Cartoon Network trashing something that had been great. Slowly, though, and...

Hot Air (2016) Review

Hot Air (2016) Review

Hot Air provides a great deal of warmth. Winner of the Comedy Vanguard Jury Award at the Austin Film Festival 2016, “Hot Air” is a quirky and gentle romantic comedy which starts with…ahem…a bang. ‘Major’ (Jere Burns) is an incorrigible conman who fakes his own death under his real...

Aquaman And The Lost Kingdom (2023) Review

Aquaman And The Lost Kingdom (2023) Review

Aquaman and the Lost Kingdom sinks the DCEU with a cinematic shipwreck that struggles to find its sea legs If you stare into the abyss long enough, you might just stat to hallucinate a movie as ill-conceived and lazily executed as Aquaman and the Lost Kingdom. Return to the...

Mr Turner (2014) Review

Mr Turner (2014) Review

I'm captivated by the eccentricity and the genius of Mike Leigh's Mr Turner. Beyond being vaguely aware he was a painter, I knew nothing of the work or life of J M W Turner. I came out of Mike Leigh’s “Mr Turner” determined to learn more about this exceptional man and keen to find out...

Europa Report (2013) Review

Europa Report (2013) Review

A Kubrickian journey to the planet Arthur C Clarke warned us about. 2013 was a pretty good year for proper, grown-up sci-fi. In amongst the blockbusters and true stories, we were treated to the astonishing Gravity and the faithfully-made but underperforming Ender’s Game. Overlooked in...

Rush (2013) Review

Rush (2013) Review

A turbocharged Chris Hemsworth and Daniel Brühl get Rush firing on all cylinders. I'm not a fan of Formula One or motor racing and so had only the vaguest awareness of both Nikki Lauda and James Hunt going into "Rush". What got my backside in a seat was partly the trailer and cast but...