Accept no substitutes. Can You Ever Forgive Me? is the real deal.

Powered by a heartfelt and deeply human central performance from Melissa McCarthy and enlivened by a gregariously louche turn from Richard E Grant, CAN YOU EVER FORGIVE ME delivers a plaintive plea for clemency on behalf of the embittered, the flawed and the dismissed.

There’s not much to like about author Lee Israel (McCarthy). She’s stubborn, cantankerous and demanding, driven by increasing desperation for validation and acclaim that slips from her grasp the more she clutches at it. Snubbed by her agent and struggling to make ends meet, she stumbles across the opportunity to make some money by embellishing letters from famous literary figures. It’s a short step from embellishments to outright forgery but revelling in her newfound vicarious acclaim and with the encouragement of her erstwhile confidante and hanger-on Jack Hock (Grant), she begins to open up to life again just as the authorities start closing in.

There’s a deliberate lack of glamour to Israel’s life and McCarthy doesn’t shy away from portraying the more unpleasant and awkward aspects of her character and yet she retains a core of sympathetic verisimilitude that keeps you on her side. Her superficial callousness is a pre-emptive defence mechanism; she’s so bruised by life that she’s built a wall and is making everyone else pay for it. Her defences are breached by the vivaciously charming and eccentric Jack Hock, an itinerant gadabout in whom Lee finds a kindred spirit, scathingly derisive of the glitterati while simultaneously pressing their metaphorical noses against the windows, longing to join the crowd inside, played with intoxicating glee by Richard E Grant.

The film wisely avoids building a false sense of ticking clock tension, preferring instead to allow the story to unfold as an inevitable tragedy, each step taken by Lee inescapably bringer her closer to her comeuppance. In her ultimate downfall, though, there is a spark of hard-earned redemption and a bittersweet commendation of the human spirit.

CAN YOU EVER FORGIVE ME achieves the primary goal of any biopic handsomely, making the viewer want to learn more about the subject but any sense that the film had missed out significant details turns out to be erroneous as, with the exception of detailing each and every forgery created, it actually manages to faithfully recreate the actual events.

can you ever forgive me? review
Score 8/10


Hi there! If you enjoyed this post, why not sign up to get new posts sent straight to your inbox?

Sign up to receive a weekly digest of The Craggus' latest posts.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

logo

Related posts

Dungeons & Dragons: Honour Amongst Thieves (2023) Review

Dungeons & Dragons: Honour Amongst Thieves (2023) Review

You won't hate the players or the game. In a cinematic landscape increasingly obsessed with taking itself too seriously, Dungeons & Dragons: Honour Among Thieves rolls for charisma and absolutely lands a Nat 20. Jonathan Goldstein and John Francis Daley have managed a rare feat...

Widows (2018) Review

Widows (2018) Review

Widows is the movie Ocean’s 8 wants to be when it grows up. With the pedigree of talent behind and in front of the camera, you’d be forgiven for expecting “Widows” to be something very special. And you’d be right, too. Director Steve McQueen, sharing screenwriting duties with Gillian...

Star Trek: First Contact (1996) Review

Star Trek: First Contact (1996) Review

"The line must be drawn here! This far, no further!" There’s a commonly held belief that even-numbered “Star Trek” films are better than the odd-numbered ones. This is a spurious correlation. In actual fact, the true axiom is that “Star Trek” films which involve Nicholas...

Loki Episode 3

Loki Episode 3

Lamentis Review It’s been observed more than once that LOKI sometimes represents Marvel’s take on DOCTOR WHO and The Time Lords in particular. In LAMENTIS, the third episode of the season, this comparison becomes particularly apt as Loki (Hiddleston) and Sylvie (Sophia Di Martino)...

Goodbye Christopher Robin (2017) Review

Goodbye Christopher Robin (2017) Review

Goodbye Christopher Robin offers us a very stiff upper lipped British tragedy. With something as pure and innocent as the adventures of Winnie The Pooh, you’d be forgiven for thinking the story of their creation would be equally as heart-warming and uplifting. But, as Simon Curtis’...

Iron Man (2008) Review

Iron Man (2008) Review

After years in the red, Marvel found itself Back In Black with Iron Man When genius, billionaire, playboy, industrialist (he's yet to graduate to philanthropist at this point) Tony Stark (Robert Downey Jr) is kidnapped and mortally wounded during a terrorist ambush in Afghanistan...

Fright Night (1985) Review

Fright Night (1985) Review

Eighties horror's love letter to fifties vampire lore. Fright Night is what happens when 80s horror brings classic vampire cinema bang up to date, moving out of the creepy castles and into into suburbia, fangs out and synthesizers blaring. Directed by Tom Holland (no, not that one), this...

Bottoms (2023) Review

Bottoms (2023) Review

Bottoms has cheek to spare Bottoms is an audacious mocktail of high school chaos and queer romance, shaken vigorously and served with a twist. I mean audacious in the most literal sense. It has audacity. The definite article, in fact. It has the audacity. Directed by Emma Seligman...