If Beale Street Could Talk conveys its most powerful messages without using words

Coming off the back of the Oscar-winning “Moonlight”, director Barry Jenkins returns to the big screen with his adaptation of James Baldwin’s novel “If Beale Street Could Talk”. In 1970’s Harlem, Tish (Kiki Layne) is in love with a young sculptor, Fonny (Stephen James), the father of her unborn child. When Fonny is falsely accused of rape and imprisoned, Tish and their families race to clear his name before the baby is born.

Bringing his trademark slow burn intensity to bear on Baldwin’s novel, Jenkins suffuses 1970s Harlem with an expressionistic almost dream-like ambience with a luxurious colour palate and long, lingering shots and signature tight close-ups on the faces of his characters, allowing the emotional weight of the movie to pour out through their eyes and into the audience’s souls.

Almost glacial in its pacing, yet spiked with moments of shocking intensity, there’s an undeniable mesmerism at work as the harsh realities of the African American experience unfold on screen. Yet despite the cruel inequity of institutionalised racism and systemic prejudice which has robbed generations of young African Americans of their freedoms and shattered the lives of their families and communities, there’s a defiant spark of seemingly impossible yet indefatigable hope, personified in Tish. KiKi Layne, making her feature debut, is astonishingly self-assured as young Tish, superficially fragile but resolute and resilient, hardening to withstand the ordeal she must go through. Regina King, likewaise, brings a quiet sense of power and vulnerability to the role of Tish’s mother, the matriarch trying to hold her family together in the face of injustice and indifferent authorities. The strength of the characters and the precarious nature of their lives is given profound expression through the performances of the wider cast too, with Stephan James and Colman Domingo lingering in the memory as well.

A poignant love story and a heartbreaking indictment of the prevailing culture of yesterday’s America – and a timely reminder to the America of today – despite the modern stylistic trappings of Jenkins’s direction and the beautiful cinematography, there’s something about the movie which feels a little old-fashioned. There’s a bleak inevitability to the way the story unfolds that feels on the brink of being archly worthy and ever-so-slightly Oscar-baity, especially when compared to recent movies which have tackled similar themes such as “Get Out” or even Jenkins’ own “Moonlight”. Even then, it’s still a stunning movie, masterfully performed by a uniformly excellent cast and worthy of attention.

if beale street could talk review
Score 8/10
logo

Related posts

The Devil’s Advocate (1997) Review

The Devil's Advocate (1997) Review

The Devil's in the details, so always check the small print. The Devil’s Advocate is a film that straddles the line between legal thriller and supernatural horror with devilish glee, offering a compelling, stylish, and surprisingly thought-provoking ride. At the heart of this Faustian...

Partir Un Jour (2025) Review

Partir Un Jour (2025) Review

Amélie Bonnin serves up a charming Cannes opener with Leave One Day. French pop star Juliette Armanet belts out club bangers in a greasy spoon and somehow it works. That might be the most succinct summation of Partir Un Jour (Leave One Day), the genre-blending, tone-juggling, deep-fried...

That Hope Is You, Part 1

That Hope Is You, Part 1

Look, everyone loved The Mandalorian but for Star Trek, this is not the way. *SPOILERS* The year is 3188, the place…is less clear. The focus of "That Hope Is You, Part 1" Star Trek Discovery's season 3 opener is…Michael Burnham. Of course. Clearly, Kurtzman is fed up of being...

Red State (2011) Review

Red State (2011) Review

Across The View Askewniverse:Red State A year after “Cop Out”, Smith returned to the big screen with a deliberately pared-down, low budget production, something very new for him and potentially very jarring for his fans – a deliberately nasty and bleak horror movie as Smith turns his...

Doctor Who: The Witchfinders Review

Doctor Who: The Witchfinders Review

The Doctor, the Witch and the wardrobe department Shirt Watch: Blue (I’m the only person doing shirt watch, aren’t I?) If last week’s episode was a move towards Doctor Who orthodoxy, “The Witchfinders” positively revels in Doctor Who tropery and it’s all the better for it. I...

Craggus’ Trek Trek Phase II Vol 19

Craggus' Trek Trek Phase II Vol 19

Relax, sit back and enjoy Craggus' Trek Trek Phase II Vol 19 Craggus' Trek Trek Phase II Vol 19 sees season six end with a strong run and season seven begin with the return of a wrong 'un. Star Trek The Next Generation S6E20: The Chase When...

Jaws 2 (1978) Review

Jaws 2 (1978) Review

Jaws 2 is better than every other shark movie save one (and you know which one that is) Just when you thought it was safe to go back in the water, Jaws 2 emerges from the depths, ready to remind us that even sequels can still have teeth. While it may not have the same razor-sharp...

The DUFF (2015) Review

The DUFF (2015) Review

The DUFF could stand for for Disappointingly Underwhelming Feature Film. Falling some way short of classic teen movie status, “The DUFF” is still a likeable and passably entertaining high school comedy version of "Pygmalion": a “She’s All That” for the “iCarly” generation. When...