Pet Sematary 2019 ReviewHandsomely produced and atmospherically shot, this re-adaptation of Stephen King’s powerful exploration of grief serves to underline the key message of the original novel: it’s best to let dead things rest.

Louis Creed (Jason Clarke), a doctor from Boston, moves to the small town of Ludlow in Maine to enjoy a quieter life and spend more time with his wife Rachel (Amy Seimetz) and their two young children, Ellie (Jeté Laurence) and Gage (Hugo Lavoie/ Lucas Lavoie). Whilst exploring the woods surrounding their new home, Ellie discovers a ‘Pet Sematary’ but is warned by neighbour Jud Crandall (Jon Lithgow) that the woods are not safe to venture out alone. When Ellie’s beloved cat Church is found dead, Jud tells Louis of a secret place in the woods which has a special power to bring Church back to life. But when Louis suffers a devastating loss of his own, the lure of the woods’ dark power becomes irresistible.

There’s a lack of certainty of purpose in this latest version of King’s novel in that it never really seems to be sure if it’s a remake of the original movie adaptation or a new adaptation of the book itself. The screenplay only exacerbates this, relying so heavily on you having seen the original movie for one of its main twists to work that it ends up feeling deeply derivative. It’s blessed with understandably superior production values to its thirty-year-old forebear and spends so much time revelling in these that it forgets to move the story forward enough, resulting in a film which simultaneously feels too slow and far too rushed. It’s a story which requires a slow, inexorable descent into the pitch-black depths of loss and grief and it’s always going to be a big ask to portray that on screen, but it would have been nice if the screenplay had even attempted it.

Lithgow’s kindly neighbour is less immediately congenial than Fred Gwynne’s take on the character, which strengthens the film but also makes his impulsive decision to reveal the secret of the woods all the more bafflingly. So much so, that the script has to have him explain it later on. It’s in Jason Clarke’s character, though, that the film suffers the most. The super-rational uber-sceptic’s damascene conversion to spiritualism is so abrupt and out of character it never feels justified or authentic. Not that it’s Clarke’s fault per se, his performance is strong – as are all the performances of the main cast – but the script lacks life and nothing short of burying it in the woods and hoping for the best will solve the problems.

4/10 

logo

Related posts

Twice Upon A Time has about half the magic it needs. Doctor Who (S10E13) #Review

Twice Upon A Time has about half the magic it needs. Doctor Who (S10E13) #Review

*SPOILERS*Christmas is, famously, a time for indulgence and “Twice Upon A Time” finds demob happy showrunner Steven Moffat and his leading man in very indulgent mood indeed.Still refusing to regenerate following the events of “The Doctor Falls”, The Doctor (Peter Capaldi) finds...

All Aboard! The Sleigh Ride (2015) Review

All Aboard! The Sleigh Ride (2015) Review

Has Black Friday left you feeling blue? Cyber Monday depleted your spirit as well as your bank account? Then come, soothe your festive soul with a mesmerising, calming documentary that redefines chilling out.Out now on DVD, “All Aboard! The Sleigh Ride” is a beautifully realised real time...

Ant-Man And The Wasp: Quantumania (2023) Review

Ant-Man And The Wasp: Quantumania (2023) Review

Dammit, Janet! Ant-Man And The Wasp: Quantumania fuses silly and sinister family secretsThe 31st release of the MCU, ANT-MAN AND THE WASP: QUANTUMANIA picks up the baton of a $29 billion-dollar-and-counting relay after the reprehensibly risible THOR: LOVE AND THUNDER and the...

Lower expectations deliver a superior return on The Nut Job 2: Nutty By Nature (2017)

Lower expectations deliver a superior return on The Nut Job 2: Nutty By Nature (2017)

Yet another in the bafflingly long list of animated films which didn’t deserve a sequel, the follow-up to 2014’s “The Nut Job” is now in UK cinemas. Here’s the surprising bit: it’s not that bad.When the Nut Shop is suddenly destroyed, Surly the squirrel (Will Arnett) is faced with the...