Episode 1 of the BBC’s new adaptation of A Christmas Carol seems to have scared the Dickens out of itself…

Episode one of A Christmas Carol, the BBC’s latest unprovoked assault involving classic literature literally opens by taking the piss, surely a record when it comes to metatextual fourth-wall breaking.

Surely we can all agree that what Charles a dickens’ classic tale of regret and redemption has been missing is a padded-out prequel detailing a Jacob Marley’s journey through purgatory which then fundamentally alters the moral of the story from one of epiphany shared and souls saved to a selfish ‘scare the bugger straight’ agenda to enable Marley to pass through purgatory.

The half-hearted reforming of Scrooge as some sort of fiscal savant, bereft of obvious empathy, unable to relate to his fellow man and obsessively driven to record patterns and numbers also thumbs its nose in the face of Dickens prose, pushing the hauntings perilously close to being punishment for being – shall we say – neurologically atypical rathe than a purgatorial attempt to warn and enlighten.

The production values are excellent but the production itself rather less than the sum of its parts. Guy Pearce may provide something for the mums but seems disengaged as the ‘tight-fisted hand at the grindstone…the squeezing, wrenching, grasping, scraping, clutching, covetous old sinner’, but then he’s never seemed that comfortable in period roles adapted from classic literature, really. The rest of the cast are satisfactory in a workmanlike way in their flat stroll through Dickens’ parable but beyond the unnecessarily expanded role for Marley, nobody yet gets a great deal to do.

Even as Jacob Marley inadvertently (one assumes) echoes Jacob Rees-Mogg’s comments on the Grenfell tragedy it becomes achingly apparent how much this archly grimdark retelling has potentially missed its mark. With Dickensian literature becoming more and more relevant to so-called modern Britain with every passing day, it takes some effort to make this story seem disconnected from the all too contemporary evils of ignorance and want but there we have it.

Of course, it’s harsh to judge definitively after only the first visitation but this interpretation is undeniably haunted by the ghosts of adaptations past and we’re in for a long three nights if this is anything to go by. Redemption has never seemed further out of reach. God help us, everyone!

A Christmas Carol
logo

Related posts

Star Trek: Picard S1E06 – The Impossible Box

Star Trek: Picard S1E06 - The Impossible Box

Six episodes in, Star Trek Picard finally gets to the point. *SPOILERS* We may have taken the long and painfully slow way round, but finally “Star Trek: Picard” brings its two storylines together and finds its Trekness again as Picard and co arrive at the Borg Reclamation Project and...

How To Train Your Dragon 2 (2014) Review

How To Train Your Dragon 2 (2014) Review

You'd be a Berk to miss the excellent How To Train Your Dragon 2. It's been four years since we were first introduced to Hiccup and Toothless on the big screen, and although that's a big gap for an animated title, we were at least treated to a couple of TV series to keep us up to date...

The Falcon And The Winter Soldier Episode 1

The Falcon And The Winter Soldier Episode 1

New World OrderReview THE FALCON AND THE WINTER SOLDIER is, obviously, a very different beast to WANDAVISION. Although it no doubt has surprises in store, it’s not setting out to deliver a mystery-box experience of weirdness and otherworldly shenanigans. In fact, from the moment...

Elf (2009) Review

Elf (2009) Review

The best way to spread Christmas Cheer, is not to admit that you're not as enamoured of Elf as everyone else seems to be. I know “Elf” enjoys a huge cult following and tops many people’s list of favourite Christmas films. The story of a human who is accidentally brought to the North Pole...

Kingdom Of The Planet Of The Apes (2024) Review

Kingdom Of The Planet Of The Apes (2024) Review

Apes together aren't strong enough to resist the clichés of the hero's journey KINGDOM OF THE PLANET OF THE APES invites viewers back to a world where human hubris has seen the species fall while simultaneously helping our successors, the apes, to rise. Set generations after...

A Nightmare on Elm Street 4: The Dream Master (1988) Review

A Nightmare on Elm Street 4: The Dream Master (1988) Review

Freddy steps out of your dreams and into the zeitgeist. A Nightmare on Elm Street 4: The Dream Master sees Freddy Krueger complete his ascent from nightmare stalker to full-blown cinematic icon. Directed by a then up-and-coming Renny Harlin, The Dream Master leans heavily into...

The Entity (1982) Review

The Entity (1982) Review

Seeing isn't believing in The Entity. The Entity may be by the same director who would go on to inflict Superman IV: The Quest for Peace on us, but don’t let that fool you—Sidney J Furie’s 1982 movie is a harrowing, unsettling horror film that transcends its early '80s trappings...

A Wrinkle In Time (2018) Review

A Wrinkle In Time (2018) Review

A Wrinkle In Time takes too long to iron out its plot Buckling under the weight of its own aspirations, Ava DuVernay’s ambitious but flawed adaptation of adaptation of "A Wrinkle In Time", Madeleine L'Engle’s perennially popular sci-fi fantasy, occasionally dazzles but all too...

3 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Ellen
Ellen
5 years ago

Not for all the Mums..!
I’m going to stick with it but until Stephen Graham can fully banish any scouse from his accent I’ll continue to be irritated by that the most.
Totally agree, the shift focus in the story has pushed the rest of it right off course. Even the token original lines from the book can’t put it back on track!

Ruthless Goat
5 years ago

I totally disagree. I left my comments about this great adaptation in my review at Ruthless Reviews. I have watched and reviewed virtually every version of A Christmas Carol, and this one rises to the top.