Unable to achieve ascension, Saint Maud finds a home in cinematic purgatory.

Rose Glass’ feature debut is a strikingly stark psychological horror, powered by two mesmeric central performances and a stylishly bleak aesthetic. Claustrophobic and intimate to the point of intrusive, it’s very well crafted and occasionally shocking but ultimately it doesn’t bring anything new to the sanctified vs psychosis trope that dwells malevolently at the heart of “Saint Maud”.

Recently ‘born again’ nurse Maud (Morfydd Clark) is preparing for a new nursing assignment and awaiting her great purpose from God. Her assignment is to provide palliative care for Amanda Kohl (Jennifer Ehle), a free-spirited former dancer, now dying of cancer but as Amanda and Maud grow closer, Maud comes to believe her great purpose is to save Amanda’s soul.

In her exploration of trauma, mortality and belief, Glass overlaps a lot of the favourite themes of Ari Aster but unlike Aster she’s able to thoroughly explore the territory with efficiency and economy, packing a lot of metaphysical content into the film’s trim 84 minutes. Much of this is down to Morfydd Clark’s phenomenally nuanced and layered performance as Maud (or is it Katie?), bringing a wealth of emotional authenticity to a character portrait of an introverted young girl deep in crisis with nobody to turn to. Vacillating between piety and wantonness, forever seeking purpose and spiritual fulfilment, it’s an astonishingly tense and uncomfortable, sustained for the entire length of the piece as she descends through devotion to fanaticism and eventually mortification.

Counterpointing the tightly wound Maud is the louche and languorous Amanda, a survivor of the cut-throat showbiz world of professional dance now facing her mortality with a mixture of hedonism and nihilistic cynicism, played by Ehle who often seems to be channelling Meryl Streep playing Norma Desmond. Glass expertly teases the audience with the faint possibility that these two lost, damaged souls will find solace and some form of salvation in each other before allowing them both to fall to their most destructive impulses, placing them both on course for tragedy.

Aside from some leadenly obvious Kafka references, visually, the film’s mix of tight close ups and ambient wide shots does a great job of underlining Maud’s increasing isolation and detachment from the world around her but it’s hard not to feel like there’s a lot of set-up for a brief and shocking final few minutes and despite the sterling work of the cast, we don’t really get to understand either of the main characters beyond where they are in their lives now. It’s a deliberate choice to lean into the conceits of ‘elevated horror’, which often mistake inscrutability for intrigue and withhold any sense of catharsis from both characters and audiences, and undercuts what’s happening on screen.

“Saint Maud” is a provocative and thought-provoking film with astonishing performances and it promises great things from Rose Glass in future but its righteous spark arrives a little too late and the smouldering tinderbox of character and emotion never manages to light the pyre.

saint maud review
score 7/10


Hi there! If you enjoyed this post, why not sign up to get new posts sent straight to your inbox?

Sign up to receive a weekly digest of The Craggus' latest posts.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

logo

Related posts

Terrifier (2016) Review

Terrifier (2016) Review

Terrifier lives up to its name in every way imaginable. Terrifier isn’t here to reinvent the slasher genre—it’s here to rip it apart, chew it up, and spit it back out with a sinister grin. Directed by Damien Leone and starring David Howard Thornton as Art the Clown, Terrifier doesn’t...

Star Trek: Deep Space Nine Season Seven Review

Star Trek: Deep Space Nine Season Seven Review

All good things must come to an end... 25 years ago, on 3rd January 1993, “Star Trek: Deep Space Nine” made its TV debut in America. It wouldn’t reach UK TV screens until 22nd August later that year. To celebrate the 25th Anniversary, What The Craggus Saw is taking the time between those...

Grease (1978) Review

Grease (1978) Review

Forty years later, Grease is very much still the word Rereleased to celebrate its 40th anniversary, “Grease” takes us to a nostalgia-fuelled retro-dystopia where middle-aged adults are forced to attend high school and endure the trials and tribulations of adolescent life, no doubt...

The Black Demon (2023) Review

The Black Demon (2023) Review

Not for the first time, big oil causes big problems in The Black Demon Just when you thought it was safe to go back to the oil rig, along comes The Black Demon, sinking its teeth not only into the flesh of its victims but into the very fabric of human conscience about environmental...

Dracula vs Frankenstein (1971) Review

Dracula vs Frankenstein (1971) Review

Ironically, only Van Helsing's mother was named Martha… With the aesthetics of a cheap seventies porno and the production values of an even cheaper seventies porno, starting life as a biker gang movie before being having Frankenstein’s monster inserted and then finally having Dracula...

The Forever Purge (2021) Review

The Forever Purge (2021) Review

The Forever Purge elevates allegorical subtlety to a masonry artform. Oh, thank God there’s another PURGE movie because I was starting to get withdrawal pangs following the end of the reality TV version which ran from 2016 to January 20th this year. Oh, sure, there’s that spin-off...

Project Daedalus

Project Daedalus

Let's all meet up with Trek's Hal-9000, won't it be strange when a background character's gone? *SPOILERS* It's action stations on "Project Daedalus" as the crew prove their fugitive bona fides by immediately contacting a Starfleet Admiral and inviting her to their hiding place...

Trap (2024) Review

Trap (2024) Review

M Night Shyamalan's latest thriller falls into a trap of its own making. The Shyamalan family is having quite the 2024, with M. Night producing his middle daughter’s directorial debut The Watched and now devoting an entire film to showcase his eldest daughter’s musical aspirations...

1 Comment
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments