Look, everyone loved The Mandalorian but for Star Trek, this is not the way.

*SPOILERS*

The year is 3188, the place…is less clear. The focus of “That Hope Is You, Part 1” Star Trek Discovery’s season 3 opener is…Michael Burnham. Of course.

Clearly, Kurtzman is fed up of being criticised too often for not living up to Rodenberry’s optimistic view of the future and has decided to do something about it. That something, it would appear, is to do away with it altogether and replace it with a fragmented, worn-out sci-fi aesthetic that feels borrowed from a long time ago and a galaxy far, far away.

Having thwarted Control’s attempts to acquire the sphere data, Burnham exits the trans-temporal wormhole some nine hundred years in the future and immediately collides with another ship sending them both crashing to the surface below. Alone and adrift, Burnham must find a way to make contact with the USS Discovery.

Michael Burnham Joy

It’s hard to ignore Kurtzman’s ongoing desire to play in the “Star Wars” sandbox and how it’s impacting every creative decision on “Star Trek Discovery”. Having brought his chosen one far enough into the future that he can ignore canon as he sees fit, in “That Hope Is You, Part 1” he immediately strands his ‘chosen one’ on a barren planet which, if there’s a bright centre to this moribund universe, is clearly the farthest from.

From the establishing shots featuring alien critters eating other alien critters in the foreground, this is a shameless application of the Lucasian vision to “Star Trek”. Never mind the episode then sees Burnham venture through the wastelands until she discovers a shifty smuggler who then takes her to the local wretched hive of scum and villainy before they manage to escape from some dispute arising from lost/ stolen cargo. There’s even a nod to the Rathtar’s from “The Force Awakens” and the episode’s title “That Hope Is You” sails pretty close to “A New Hope”.  

Star Trek Discovery Aliens

It remains to be seen how much the apparent collapse of the Federation and the MacGuffining of dilithium into Kurtzman’s version of Coaxium after most of it abruptly blew up…for some reason will impact the storytelling of this new era of Star Trek, but I’ll lay odds on them not doing very much exploring between now and season’s end.

It’s not all Kurtzman calamity though. “That Hope Is You, Part 1” looks fantastic and the production values are probably higher than any other individual Trek pisode or movie thanks in large part to the extensive location shooting in Iceland. Must have been expensive though, because director Olatunde Osunsanmi makes sure to include as much of it as he possibly can in the frame, whether it detracts from the character action on screen or not.

Sonequa Martin-Green continues to deliver a great performance as Starfleet’s most emotionally unstable Vulcan-conditioned officer and the script asks her to do a lot of crying, which is a shame. She’s much better when given better material to work with whether it’s the superb moment she scans for life and realises her mission to defeat Control was a success (obviously we knew, but it’s nice that the writers remembered that she wouldn’t) or when she’s under the influence of an interrogative intoxicant.

Likewise, Book (David Ajala), the show’s new Han Solo/ Lando Calrissian mashup, makes a strong first impression, even if his ‘scoundrel with a heart of gold’ character is by this point a venerable genre cliché.

Flying The Flag Of The Federation

Given its slow pace, there’s still a surprising amount of violence crammed into the runtime and not much in the way of the exploration of ideas. It’s still hard not to feel this is a show which talks about Starfleet and the Federation a lot without ever understanding Starfleet (or “Star Trek” itself) at all. Still, let’s see what comes of this one giant leap and give the series time to take hopefully more than one small step in the right direction of regaining the spirit of The Great Bird Of The Galaxy, but with the same showrunners still at the helm? Yeesh.

I’ve got a bad feeling about this [season].

star trek discovery s3e01 that hope is you part 1

Season 3 Episode 01

star trek discovery season 3
trek score 5


Hi there! If you enjoyed this post, why not sign up to get new posts sent straight to your inbox?

Sign up to receive a weekly digest of The Craggus' latest posts.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

1 Comment
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
star trek discovery s1e01 the vulcan hello
star trek discovery s1e02 battle at the binary stars
star trek discovery s1e03 context is for kings
star trek discovery s1e04 the butcher's knife cares not for the lamb's cry
star trek discovery s1e05 choose your pain
star trek discovery s1e06 lethe
star trek discovery s1e07 magic to make the sanest man go mad
star trek discovery s1e08 si vis pacem, para bellum
star trek discovery s1e09 into the forest i go
star trek discovery s1e10 despite yourself
star trek discovery s1e11 the wolf inside
star trek discovery s1e12 vaulting ambition
star trek discovery s1e13 what's past is prologue
star trek discovery s1e14 the war without the war within
star trek discovery s1e15 will you take my hand?
star trek discovery s2e01 brother
star trek discovery s2e02 new eden
star trek discovery s1e03 point of light
star trek discovery s2e04 an obol for charon
star trek discovery s2e05 saints of imperfection
star trek discovery s2e06 the sound of thunder
star trek discovery s2e07 light and shadows
star trek discovery s2e08 if memory serves
star trek discovery s2e09 project daedalus
star trek discovery s2e10 the red angel
star trek discovery s2e11 perpetual infinity
star trek discovery s2e12 through the valley of shadows
star trek discovery s2e13 such sweet sorrow
star trek discovery s2e14 such sweet sorrow part ii
star trek discovery s3e02 far from home
star trek discovery s3e03 people of earth
star trek discovery s3e04 forget me not
star trek discovery s3e05 die trying
star trek discovery s3e06 scavengers
star trek discovery s3e07 unification iii
star trek discovery s3e08 the sanctuary
star trek discovery s3e09 terra firma part 1
star trek discovery s3e10 terra firma part 2
star trek discovery s3e11 su'kal
star trek discovery s3e12 there is a tide...
star trek discovery s3e13 that hope is you part 2
logo

Related posts

Christmas With The Coopers (2015) Review

Christmas With The Coopers (2015) Review

Christmas With The Coopers will get you right in the family feels. (Christmas) Cards on the table: I’ve got a sentimental streak a mile wide and it’s particularly attuned to Christmastime. You might have assumed from the trailer and marketing that this is a frothy, kooky slapstick comedy...

Treehouse Of Horror III

Treehouse Of Horror III

This time, it's Homer's turn to open the "Treehouse Of Horror III" show, with a tribute to Alfred Hitchcock, Naturally, Homer's approach to the crybabies - religious types mostly - is somewhat more abrasive than Marge's but it does result in Homer's swearing on a book of carpet samples...

King Kong (1933) Review

King Kong (1933) Review

Now here's the real king of the swingers; the original jungle VIP One of those classic movies that establishes itself and its themes so powerfully and skilfully that almost every aspect of the production has become iconic in its own right, KING KONG (1933) was a seismic event in...

Virus Shark (2021) Review

Virus Shark (2021) Review

Symptoms of Virus Shark include incoherent plotting, lifeless dull performances and a burning desire to turn it off Great art has always explored and illuminated the societal concerns of its era. But shit art can do that too, and Virus Shark is bad shark movies’ answer to the...

Duck Duck Goose (2018) is worth a gander.

Duck Duck Goose (2018) is worth a gander.

Duck Duck Goose is worth a gander. A good voice cast and beautifully animated backdrops of the stunning geography of China are enough to lift this undemanding animated animal fable above the flock. When reckless goose Peng (Jim Gaffigan) passes up the chance to migrate with the rest...

Shaun The Sheep Movie (2015) Review

Shaun The Sheep Movie (2015) Review

The title grammar may be baaaad but Shaun The Sheep Movie isn't the black sheep of the Aardman movies It’s unlikely the target audience of the latest family-friendly stop-motion feature from Aardman will be as bothered by the grammar of the title as I am (not The Shaun The Sheep...

Unfriended (2015) Review

Unfriended (2015) Review

Web-based horror flick Unfriended gives us a very anti-social network. I have to say, I honestly thought the first real foray into ‘social networking’ horror movie would be some form of Snapchat exchange movie, where the plot unfolds in a series of 10 second vignettes building up to some...

Sleepaway Camp (1983) Review

Sleepaway Camp (1983) Review

Sleepaway Camp offers very little sleep but a whole lotta camp. There’s nothing remotely subtle about 1983 slasher “Sleepaway Camp” – from the moment the first images of the empty Camp Arawak site to the accompaniment of shrieking horns and ominous chords, this film is working hard to...