What If The Watcher Broke His Oath

Opening in the continuity of WHAT IF… CAPTAIN CARTER WERE THE FIRST AVENGER? with the very beginning of Captain Carter’s version of THE WINTER SOLDIER (something it’s rumoured that WHAT IF…? Season 2 will circle back to cover), WHAT IF…THE WATCHER BROKE HIS OATH? begins with our constant narrator doing just that in spectacular fashion as he raids previous episodes of the series (and, in one case an unfinished episode) to recruit a team of Guardians Of The Multiverse in an attempt to neutralise the omnipresent threat of the multiversal Ultron.

In addition to Captain Carter, we get Star-Lord T’Challa (as well as a brief glimpse of Ego and that universe’s Peter Quill), Killmonger, party boy Thor and an appearance by an alternative Tony Stark and Gamora on Nidavellir (from the unfinished episode) which results, much to Tony’s chagrin, in Gamora being recruited and not him. Brought together by the Watcher and dark Doctor Strange,

Where previous episodes have muddled through with mostly replacement cast members, this season finale immediately impresses with its collection of original cast. Chris Hemsworth, Benedict Cumberbatch, Michael B Jordan and Hayley Atwell all report for duty and Kurt Rusell himself returns to deliver Ego’s single line of dialogue. Of course, this episode is destined for notability for one poignant reason: it gives us the final performance of Chadwick Boseman before his untimely death.

While WHAT IF… THE WATCHER BROKE HIS OATH? may not be the epitaph anyone would have chosen, it does at least provide a suitably epic setting for T’Challa’s last appearance, pulling together every single episode of the series thus far – yes, including the zombie one in a battle which spans multiple worlds and multiple rounds without ever feeling forced or repetitive.

In common with many of the Marvel Disney+ series, it does feel like a pretty good (in this case animated) movie has been padded out to provide enough content to be serialised across multiple weeks in service of a subscription-building strategy. As the Marvel content conveyor belt gets ever more crowded, spreading a multiverse across multiple platforms, you have to wonder how much room there will continue to be for quirky little side projects like this.

Score 8

8/10

logo

Related posts

Muppets Most Wanted (2014) Review

Muppets Most Wanted (2014) Review

I enjoy the great Muppet caper that is Muppets Most Wanted. You always know what to expect when a new Muppet movie comes around: there'll be spectacle, there'll be fantasy, there'll be derring-do and stuff like you would never see. There'll be heroes bold, there'll be comedy, and a lot...

Return To Oz (1985) Review

Return To Oz (1985) Review

Dark Disney does Oz. If The Wizard of Oz was a Technicolor dream that enraptured audiences with its warmth, whimsy, and timeless tunes, then Return to Oz was its shadow opposite, a starkly different kind of journey—one that many audiences found deeply unsettling. With its darker tone...

Star Trek: Picard S1E05 – Stardust City Rag

Star Trek: Picard S1E05 - Stardust City Rag

  I am in Star Trek Picard stepped in so far that should I wade no more, returning were as tedious as go o’er. *SPOILERS* Judging by “Stardust City Rag”, which brings us to the halfway point of this debut season of “Star Trek Picard”, the raison d'être for this series would...

Doctor Who: Hell Bent Review

Doctor Who: Hell Bent Review

Hell Bent is the end of an era in Doctor Who, but the moment has been prepared for... I’ve taken the luxury of watching “Hell Bent” a few times now, savouring its courage and ambition. As a season finale it’s a curious beast, lacking the overt bombastic urgency...

The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey (2012) Review

The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey (2012) Review

There and back again. Well, at least part of the way there. Returning to Middle Earth should feel like slipping into a well-worn cloak, but The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey arrives with a different energy. This is not the brooding, weighty journey of The Lord of the Rings; this is a...

Doctor Who: Boom

Doctor Who: Boom

Moffat's return to Doctor Who is a literal minefield with plenty of "Kiss Kiss" but will there be a "Bang Bang" in Boom? With Davies’ return, DOCTOR WHO once again embraced more character-driven, emotional storytelling as a welcome antidote to the thematically rich but...