There’s a real sense of “been there, Dune that” to Denis Villeneuve’s take on the legendary sci-fi classic

Lethargically paced and inertly beautiful, Dennis Villeneuve’s DUNE arrives in cinemas frustratingly incomplete, disappointingly hollow and surprisingly hesitant in vision and execution.

Threatened by the growing power of House Atreides, the galactic Emperor awards Duke Leto Atreides (Oscar Isaac) stewardship of the planet Arrakis, also known as Dune and the only source of the most valuable substance in the universe, the spice Melange. The Emperor is seeking to pit House Harkonnen, the previous stewards of Arrakis, against House Atreides and rid himself of a threat to the throne. While Leto, aware of the trap being set, seeks an alliance with the mysterious Fremen natives of Arrakis, his son Paul (Timothée Chalamet) finds himself confronting a very different destiny.

Frank Herbert’s epic, sweeping novel of intergalactic faith, war and politics has long thwarted the cinema but hopes were justifiably high when it fell to visionary director Denis Villeneuve to reimagine it for 21st Century movie-going audiences but sadly it appears that the task was no easier for him than those who went before him. Avante-Garde director Alejandro Jodorowsky tried and failed to adapt Herbert’s 1965 novel in the late seventies but it would be nearly twenty years after the novel was published before it would finally make it to the screen in David Lynch’s highly ambitious but deeply flawed 1984 adaptation. It’s therefore something of a surprise, then, that Villeneuve’s version, for a large portion of its run time, offers little more than a modern polish on the visuals that Lynch originated. Of course, the effects and production values are more polished but minor tweaks and variations aside, it’s surprising how familiar the big visual moments feel.

Even in the costumes – exquisite tailoring alone does not a sci-fi epic make – there’s a timidity to the aesthetic, a sense of restraint that undermines the movie at every turn. Jodorowsky wanted to make it too weird. Lynch, in his own inimitable style, embraced the weirdness and made a movie that’s simultaneously gorgeous to look at and gruesomely ugly – the Bene Gesserit are bald and austere and freaky looking, Baron Harkonnen is a loathsome, bubonic monster but Villeneuve’s DUNE feels too safely stylish. Fear may be the mind-killer, the little death that brings total oblivion, but it’s also corrosive to creative courage.

The starry cast is decent enough, although hardly anyone gets enough screen time to flesh out their characters beyond Chalamet’s Paul Atreides, who seems to be the only person in the cosmos unaware of his imminent messianic actualisation. The galactic high political manoeuvring feels remote and poorly articulated and despite his best efforts, Villeneuve hasn’t found a way to deliver the heavy load of exposition required by the story that’s any more elegant than Lynch’s attempt and at least Lynch’s compressed version of the story rattles along at a fair pace whereas this languid film, over-enamoured with its own hardware, strays too often into dusty dullness rather than dream-heavy destiny.

Of course, it’s difficult for any artist to go all out when tasked with filming a borderline unfilmable novel with no guarantee that you’ll be given the chance to complete the story and for that, Warner Bros must shoulder almost all the blame for the incomplete and unsatisfying film that is 2021’s DUNE. The decision not to film the entire thing back-to-back or, at the very least, firmly commit to filming both movies in advance has done more damage to this ambitious but overly-cautious adaptation than any flights of creative indulgence could ever have done.

Dune Review
Score 7/10
logo

Related posts

Batman v Superman: Of Cabbages and Kings

Batman v Superman: Of Cabbages and Kings

"Of cabbages and kings": a deleted scene* from my #BatmanvSuperman Review *This originally started as a section of my “Batman v Superman: Dawn Of Justice” review before I realised it was kind of becoming its own thing and if Warner Bros can release a deleted scene so soon after the movie...

Dracula (1979) Review

Dracula (1979) Review

He's bringing sexy Drac. Back in 1979, Universal dusted off its back catalogue and made plans to make a feature film featuring Dracula for the first time since 1948. And they didn’t even think to wrap a whole shared universe around it, dark or otherwise. Ah, those were the...

Arrival (2016) Review

Arrival (2016) Review

You'll never look at coffee mug rings the same way again If alien invasion movies exist on a spectrum where, say, “Independence Day” is the median point and down one end of the spectrum you have the likes of “Battleship” and “Independence Day: Resurgence”, “Arrival” finds its place...

Zathura: A Space Adventure (2006) Review

Zathura: A Space Adventure (2006) Review

Jon Favreau's underrated family sci-fi romp is an absolute blast (off). Long before there were thoughts of a sequel which defied all logic and was actually really, really good there was another follow-up to Jumanji. One that didn’t reprise the jungle-based adventure game itself but...

Daredevil – Season Three Review

Daredevil - Season Three Review

Season Three pivots Daredevil away from mysticism and back to the mean streets. Daredevil Season Three consciously steps away from the expansive introductory detours of the previous season, anchoring itself firmly in the conflict at the heart of Hell's Kitchen: Matt Murdock versus Wilson...

The Hundred-Foot Journey (2014) Review

The Hundred-Foot Journey (2014) Review

The Hundred-Foot Journey is a trip well worth taking. A clash of cultures and culinary artistry lies at the heart of this warm and witty comedy-drama, bolstered by gorgeous cinematography and some great performances. While food is undoubtedly at the core of the movie, adapted from...

Mission: Impossible – Rogue Nation (2015) Review

Mission: Impossible - Rogue Nation (2015) Review

Despite Cruise's efforts to hog the limelight, it's Rebecca Ferguson who rules Mission: Impossible - Rogue Nation Back for a fifth instalment, “Mission: Impossible – Rogue Nation” finds Ethan Hunt facing off against two distinct threats. One is The Syndicate, a shadow network which...

The Comey Rule (2020) Review

The Comey Rule (2020) Review

The only thing that was necessary for the triumph of evil was for a good man to do the 'right' thing. “The Comey Rule”, based on the memoirs of the ex-head of the FBI, James Comey, splits very clearly into two eras: BE, Before the Election – and AE. Detailing the events and...