If a man is the sum of his memories, Mickey 17 is the sum of his mortalities.

Existence is cheap in Mickey 17, and Robert Pattinson’s Mickey Barnes knows it better than anyone. He’s an “Expendable,” a human-shaped insurance policy against workplace hazards on the ice-locked hellscape of Niflheim. If he dies – and he will – another copy rolls off the printer, memories intact, ready to die all over again. It’s an arrangement that works just fine until one day, it doesn’t. Mickey survives. And so does his replacement.

Bong Joon Ho is no stranger to twisting genre conventions into social satire, and here he takes the disposable workforce concept and runs it through a darkly comic, existential meat grinder. There’s a distinct whiff of The Prestige if you swapped stage magic for corporate cost-cutting and added the kind of bone-dry absurdity that made Parasite so sharp. Pattinson, ever game for characters in various states of unravelling, plays both versions of Mickey with a wearied, deadpan fatalism, watching himself play out a losing hand (sometimes literally) with no good moves left.

Mark Ruffalo relishes the role of the colony’s smarmy leader, Kenneth Marshall, a failed politician and would-be messianic overlord. He’s the kind of man who talks grandiloquently about “the greater good” while gleefully throwing bodies into a meat grinder and hoarding resources while luxuriating with his entitled, self-centred spouse Ylfa (Toni Collette), exuding the kind of callous, autocratic malevolence that can justify just about anything in the name of creating the perfect sauce – because for her, justice matters less than jus. The bleakness of Mickey’s life would be unbearable were it not for Naomi Ackie’s Nasha who brings warmth, tenderness and a little actual humanity at the shrinking moral centre of a mission that treats human life like a fungible and disposable row in the grand spreadsheet of military-industrial corporate priorities.

Bong crafts a world that’s equal parts grungy techno-dystopia and frozen wilderness, a fusion cocktail of Starship Troopers social satire and the absurdist bureaucratic nightmare of Terry Gilliam’s Brazil. It’s sci-fi that doesn’t lean on spectacle so much as character and concept, bolstered by a reliably winning multiple performances from Pattinson who manages to make every Mickey – no matter how brief their screen time – feel both unique and still familiar, a pitch-black parody of Doctor Who‘s regeneration and the multi-Doctor story that series would never dare give us. Darius Khondji’s cinematography captures the cold indifference of both the ship and the planet in every frame, making those fleeting moments of warmth shine out like flickering candles in the dark. The film’s production design revels in that unsettling contrast between the futuristic and functionally lived-in, giving the more high-concept sci-fi a solid grounding.

If there’s a flaw, it’s that the film’s reach exceeds its grasp, and it can’t quite do justice to all of its ideas. In focusing on Mickey’s story – central as it is – Mickey 17 is forced to be economical with the world-building and we’re left to piece together the scraps of information gleaned from glimpses and fleeting references. The nature of the “church” with which Kenneth Marshall has allied himself to in order to bolster his power or the colony’s social hierarchy as they remain shipbound and under siege from the planet’s icy winter is frustratingly light on detail and the movie often skirts the edge of profundity before snapping back to its more nihilistically comic roots. In a genre stuffed with stories about rugged individualism and heroic survival, Mickey 17 is refreshingly altruistic and pro-co-operative. It doesn’t ask whether humanity will conquer the stars – it simply shrugs and assumes we will and that we’ll still be clocking in for minimum wage when we get there, so it’s important that we look out for one another – and anything we might meet out there.

mickey 17 review
Score 8/10


Hi there! If you enjoyed this post, why not sign up to get new posts sent straight to your inbox?

Sign up to receive a weekly digest of The Craggus' latest posts.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

logo

Related posts

Cruel Jaws (1995) Review

Cruel Jaws (1995) Review

Cruel Jaws ends Shark Weak 4 on a profoundly stupid, deeply ignorant and poorly made low note Directed by notorious Italian filmmaker Bruno Mattei – renowned for repurposing other films’ footage to suit himself – CRUEL JAWS may just be the most tired and badly made JAWS rip-off of...

Inherent Vice (2015) Review

Inherent Vice (2015) Review

I was going to write a detailed and logical Inherent Vice but then I got high. It’s little wonder the most common witticism being thrown around in respect of Paul Thomas Anderson’s latest is 'Incoherent Vice'. It’s almost irresistible - and already has a dedicated Twitter feed to...

Saint Maud (2020) Review

Saint Maud (2020) Review

Unable to achieve ascension, Saint Maud finds a home in cinematic purgatory. Rose Glass’ feature debut is a strikingly stark psychological horror, powered by two mesmeric central performances and a stylishly bleak aesthetic. Claustrophobic and intimate to the point of intrusive, it’s...

League Of Gods (2016) Review

League Of Gods (2016) Review

League Of Gods assembles the gods of Chinese mythology as the latest super-team. With China’s growing importance as an export market for Hollywood, it was inevitable that the Chinese film industry would start to eye the possibility of making some exports of their own. “League Of Gods”...

Ferdinand (2017) Review

Ferdinand (2017) Review

Ferdinand tries to substitute good storytelling with a load of bull. Adapted from Munro Leaf’s beloved 1936 children’s book, Blue Sky Studio’s “Ferdinand” is also a remake of Disney’s 1938 Silly Symphony short of the same story. In light of the proposed acquisition of Fox by Disney, this...

The Witch (2016) Review

The Witch (2016) Review

If you go down to the woods today… There’s little actual horror in Robert Eggers’ directorial debut – at least not in the sense the genre has come to rely on in recent years. There are no jump scares, manufactured shock moments, gratuitous gore or sadistic violence. Instead, Eggers has...

Hellboy: The Crooked Man (2024) Review

Hellboy: The Crooked Man (2024) Review

Hellboy's post-del Toro curse is still in effect. Hellboy has had a rough go of it on screen. Guillermo del Toro’s baroque beauty and tender affection for the character didn’t fully translate into box office success, and the 2019 reboot came across more like a highlight reel of grotesque...

Nativity Rocks! (2018) Review

Nativity Rocks! (2018) Review

Nativity Rocks! is a kid-friendly cornucopia of sentimental nonsense. Opening with a somewhat harrowing sequence showing the arrival and separation of a father and son pair of illegal immigrants – unhinted at by the happy-clappy trailers – “Nativity Rocks!” quickly settles down into the...