The Disaster Artist sees James Franco make a great film out of a terrible movie.

From the last days of Pompeii, through Titanic to The Hindenburg, Hollywood has a long history of adapting disasters into motion pictures, so it was only a matter of time before Tommy Wiseau’s magnificent octopus was itself finally turned into an unironically watchable movie.

When aspiring actor Greg Sestero (Dave Franco) encounters the bizarre and enigmatic Tommy Wiseau (James Franco) in an acting class, they quickly form a form a strange and intense friendship. Intoxicated by his new friends’ unrestrained and larger than life personality, it’s not long before the pair decide to move to Hollywood and make their big-screen dreams come true. So begins the crazy but true tale of the making of “The Room”.

Of course, much of the magic of “The Room” is in the mystery surrounding its visionary creator and Franco’s adaptation of Greg Sestero’s memoir makes an effort to keep the enigma intact while still shedding plenty of light on the chaos of the movie’s making.

Franco’s performance as Wiseau is dazzlingly good, attacking the absurdities and foibles of the man yet still sympathetically enough that you buy into his sincere desire to realise a dream which may exceed his grasp. You also get a feel for how much his friendship with Sestero meant to him and how deeply the perceived betrayals must have hurt. Of course, every insight or revelation Franco provides us only serves to raise even more questions and deepen the mystery. Like his brother, Dave Franco also turns in a tremendous performance, arguably his career best as Sestero struggles between ambition and loyalty to his friend, mentor and/ or co-dependent.

For those who have seen the room, half the joy of this movie is in seeing key moments coming into being or re-enacted with an attention to detail that is simply astonishing (a sequence of side by side scene comparisons during the end credits not only attest to this but raise the tantalising prospect that Franco and co may just have made a shot-for-shot remake of the whole movie as the ultimate bonus feature) but the film is well crafted and balanced enough to captivate and entertain even if you haven’t seen the movie at the heart of all the drama. Of course, if you haven’t seen the original, you might be tempted to conclude “The Disaster Artist” is exaggerating for comic effect but trust me, they are not.

With the movie rounded out by a star-studded cast including the likes of Zac Efron, Josh Hutcherson, Brian Cranston, Seth Rogen and many others, it’s not hard to see how fondly “The Room” is regarded by the very industry it was made to impress. “The Disaster Artist” confirms once and for all that Wiseau has finally achieved everything he wanted to by making the film, just – by every conceivable measure – not the way he’d intended. He even gets to appear in a critically lauded Hollywood production thanks to a post-credits stinger which means you need to stay in your seat until the very end.

“The Room” may be a work of accidental, unintentional genius but “The Disaster Artist” is a deliberate, joyous triumph.

the disaster artist review
Score 9/10


Hi there! If you enjoyed this post, why not sign up to get new posts sent straight to your inbox?

Sign up to receive a weekly digest of The Craggus' latest posts.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

logo

Related posts

Die Hard (1988) Review

Die Hard (1988) Review

Willis and Rickman headline a Christmas? classic. Few films have left a mark on the action genre - or annual internet discourse - as indelibly as Die Hard. Released in 1988, John McTiernan’s high-octane thriller redefined the blueprint for action cinema with its blend of tight pacing...

Inherent Vice (2015) Review

Inherent Vice (2015) Review

I was going to write a detailed and logical Inherent Vice but then I got high. It’s little wonder the most common witticism being thrown around in respect of Paul Thomas Anderson’s latest is 'Incoherent Vice'. It’s almost irresistible - and already has a dedicated Twitter feed to...

Jackpot! (2024) Review

Jackpot! (2024) Review

Jackpot! isn't quite the winning line it thinks it is. While The Legend Of Zorro waits patiently for its turn to be chosen for Friday Night Movie Night, an upstart pretender stole its chance this week as we take in the Awkwafina/ John Cena comedy caper Jackpot! It's not a huge...

Trailer Park Shark (2017) Review

Trailer Park Shark (2017) Review

Trailer Park Shark is not-so great white trailer trash By now I’m used to sharksploitation movies being garbage, but “Trailer Park Shark” takes it to a whole new level of Great White trash. Oh, and to save you some time, if you’re thinking of watching this because it ‘stars’...

The Lego Movie (2014)

The Lego Movie (2014)

All in all, it's a bit more than just another brick in the wall... Denmark has given the world many things: excellent bacon, the works of Hans Christian Andersen and Vikings to name but a few. And while it may be difficult to admire their overly harsh approach to giraffe population...

The Toxic Avenger (2025) Review

The Toxic Avenger (2025) Review

Toxie scrubs up pretty well. Shot in 2021, premiered in 2023, and finally dragged into cinemas in 2025 by the scruff of its mutant neck, Macon Blair’s update of one of Troma’s least toxic productions has spent so long on the shelf that it's almost exceed its half-life. This incarnation...