In Vaughan’s hands, Stardust becomes the stuff of legend.

A fallen star, a lovesick boy, sky pirates, witches, and a wall that shouldn’t be crossed – Stardust hurls all its elements into the cauldron and conjures something genuinely rare: a fantasy adventure that remembers stories are meant to be fun. With Matthew Vaughn at the helm, this 2007 gem swashbuckles through danger and desire with such infectious energy it’s a wonder it hasn’t been declared a national treasure.

There’s a bravado to the film’s tone – a playful defiance of the ponderous self-seriousness that plagued much of early-2000s fantasy. Where other films trudge through the mud of destiny and prophecy, Stardust sprints across enchanted moors, its boots barely touching the ground. It owes much of this lift to Vaughn’s direction, which blends classical fantasy iconography with an irreverent modern snap. He keeps the camera light on its feet, sweeping through spell-slinging duels and airborne clashes with a giddy sense of spectacle, while never losing sight of the human hearts beating beneath the magic.

Unlike the source material, which often keeps its characters and emotions at a wry, ironic distance, Stardust the film leans into the romance, the peril, and the whimsy with open-hearted sincerity. Where the novel enjoys toying with fairytale tropes from a detached vantage point, Vaughn’s adaptation dives straight into the heart of them, shaping something that plays as a fairytale in earnest, rather than a commentary on one. Nowhere is this more evident than in the creation of Captain Shakespeare. The book’s sky pirates barely register – nameless, functional, and forgettable. The film turns them into scene-stealers, led by Robert De Niro’s flamboyant and unexpectedly tender Shakespeare, who doesn’t just help Tristan on his way but embodies the film’s message about identity, reinvention, and self-acceptance. Touches like these aren’t just embellishments – they’re elevations, a testament to Vaughan’s and co-writer Jane Goldman’s skill in taking the source material and bringing it to the screen in its most cinematic, swashbuckling and satisfying form.

Charlie Cox anchors the film with the kind of performance that quietly builds into something irresistible. His Tristan starts off as a bit of a wet blanket – the kind of romantic lead who needs a good cosmic slap – but the script lets him learn and earn his heroism step by step along his almost literal hero’s journey. By the time he’s dashing through the skies in a snatched coat and a pirate’s swagger, he’s not just pretending – he’s transformed. Opposite him, Claire Danes glows in more ways than one as Yvaine. Her star is no damsel, and Danes gives her the perfect balance of exasperated sarcasm and emotional vulnerability, never letting the literal shine of the role overpower its sincerity.

But it’s the supporting cast that turns Stardust from a solid fantasy flick into a full-blown delight. Michelle Pfeiffer is a joyously wicked witch, relishing every glamoured smirk and spiteful curse. Her descent from sultry seductress to crumbling hag plays like a darkly comic reversal of the typical fairytale transformation. Robert De Niro flips expectations with the subtlety of a skyship broadside and has rarely looked like he’s having this much fun. Even aside from those two scene-stealing turns, the film boasts an almost obscene wealth of talent in its supporting cast from Peter O’Toole as the dying King of Stormhold, to his nefarious sons, played with magnificent malevolence by the likes of Mark Strong, Rupert Everett, Jason Flemyng, Mark Heap, Julian Rhind-Tutt and Adam Buxton to Pfeiffer’s fellow witches Empusa (Sarah Alexander), Mormo (Joanna Scanlan) and Melanie Hill’s gloriously grubby Ditchwater Sal. Only Ricky Gervais’ brief cameo as Ferdy The Fence strikes a bum note, briefly breaking the otherwise immersive experience of life beyond The Wall.

The worldbuilding is brisk but evocative – a collage of storybook fantasy tropes glued together with attitude and affection. The market in Wall, the royal family’s Macbethian scramble for the throne, the ghosts who hang around to provide sardonic commentary – it all feels cohesive, even as it careens from one absurd delight to another. Vaughn keeps the pace tight and the stakes personal, sidestepping the bloat that so often plagues fantasy epics. Crucially, Stardust is brave enough not to chase the shadow of Jackson’s Lord of the Rings. Where so many contemporaries clumsily tried to mimic Middle-earth’s mournful grandeur, Vaughn charts his own star-swept course – brighter, cheekier, and completely uninterested in competing on the same axis. It’s not lesser for being lighter; it’s liberating.

It also understands romance, which is more than can be said for most of its peers. The central relationship is allowed to simmer, spark, and properly complicate. Tristan’s initial object of affection – Sienna Miller’s deliciously superficial Victoria – is the kind of red herring that makes the payoff all the sweeter. The love story between Tristan and Yvaine earns its wings, not through overwrought declarations, but shared peril, slow trust, and a third-act kiss that genuinely lands.

There’s something almost radical about how optimistic Stardust is. It’s not naïve, and it doesn’t shy away from darkness – hearts are literally cut out, people die creatively, and the villains aren’t shy about getting nasty – but the tone remains buoyant. It believes in transformation, in redemption, and above all in the power of stories to surprise. In a cinematic landscape where fantasy often means franchise fatigue and grey-filtered doom, Stardust is a reminder that adventure can be both romantic and ridiculous, earnest and exhilarating.

It may not have lit up the box office like some of its contemporaries, but Stardust has aged better than most of them. It’s a film that feels hand-forged – the work of a director and cast having the time of their lives, daring to make a fairy tale that’s neither ironic nor saccharine. And in doing so, they struck gold. Or stardust, if you like.

stardust review
stardust review
Score 10/10


Hi there! If you enjoyed this post, why not sign up to get new posts sent straight to your inbox?

Sign up to receive a weekly digest of The Craggus' latest posts.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

8 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Realweegiemidget Reviews

Loved this post Craggus – you have captured this film fantastically in a post that was as immersive as the film itself. Thanks for a wonderful double bill, and bringing these films to life in our blogathon in two great reads.

trackback
[…] things off today is the second of Craig at The Craggus‘ entries with Stardust (2007), a fantasy adventure with dashing heroes, wicked witches and a fallen […]
Chris
9 months ago

Have never heard of this film but sounds like something I would really enjoy…thanks for enlightening me! Looking forward to finding it.

Daffny
9 months ago

I love fantasy films! I really enjoyed your review! I must add this to my queue! 🙂

John
9 months ago

Didn’t this film get rushed off as being a bit poor on release? Your review has piqued my interest now. I’ll have to keep an eye out for this one.

Mary
9 months ago

An underrated film that deserves more love, imho. Matthew Vaughn at his best.

John Harmon
John Harmon
9 months ago

I’ve never seen Stardust, but your enthusiasm for this film makes me want to see it! Plus, that cast sounds too good to pass up!

logo

Related posts

Mr Holmes (2015) Review

Mr Holmes (2015) Review

It’s mortality rather than Moriarty troubling Sherlock in the absorbing drama Mr Holmes. It’s mortality rather than Moriarty who stalks the world’s greatest detective in “Mr. Holmes”, Bill Condon’s quietly engrossing portrait of a legend in decline. Based on Mitch Cullen’s novel “A...

Vacation (2015) Review

Vacation (2015) Review

Vacation makes me want to lie down on Holiday Road and wait for a truck to run me over. Aggressively stupid and often stupidly aggressive, “Vacation” is the latest RebooMaQuel™ to believe that mining our collective nostalgia and upgrading that fondness with much edgier, filthier...

Dracula (1958) Review

Dracula (1958) Review

Stop! Hammer time! Hammer Films brought Dracula bang up to date by going back to the story’s roots, adapting Stoker’s novel – with a few twists – and bringing the famed Count back to life in all his technicolour glory. When Jonathan Harker (John Van Eyssen) accepts a position as...

Mnemophrenia (2019) Review

Mnemophrenia (2019) Review

Appropriately, Mnemophrenia will linger in your thoughts for a long time… You know that feeling when you’ve had a really vivid dream and someone has done something to upset and annoy you and once you’ve woken up, you can shake the feelings of hurt and resentment immediately so they...

Super Shark (2011) Review

Super Shark (2011) Review

Look! Up in the sky! It's absurd! It's a shame! Yes, it's Super Shark! Imbued with special powers by a toxic waste spill, mild-mannered ocean dweller Shark Kent dedicates himself to using his newfound abilities to fight for truth, justice and...nope. As fun as that movie would be...

The Front Runner (2019) Review

The Front Runner (2019) Review

The Front Runner stumbles right out of the gate. Jason Reitman’s dull but dutiful checkbox biopic rakes over the long-dead ashes of the run-up to the 1988 US Presidential election but fails to find anything to really say beyond a milquetoast critique of the current personality politics...